Located in the heart of Mt Gilead, Ohio, 8 Sisters Bakery Cafe stands as a welcoming destination for those who appreciate the simple joys of freshly prepared food and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Situated at 6200 OH-95 #300, this local establishment has become a familiar stop for residents and travelers alike who are looking for a place to pause, relax, and enjoy a quality meal. Our philosophy is rooted in the belief that food should be made with care, using traditional methods that prioritize flavor and consistency. Whether you are starting your morning with a quiet cup of coffee or stopping by for a midday break, our doors are open to provide a comfortable environment where you can feel right at home.
The essence of 8 Sisters Bakery Cafe lies in our commitment to the community. We understand that a cafe is more than just a place to eat; it is a space where neighbors connect and stories are shared. By focusing on a menu that highlights classic recipes and reliable ingredients, we strive to offer something that appeals to a wide variety of tastes. Our team works diligently to ensure that every visitor receives friendly service and that the quality of our offerings remains high, day after day. We take pride in being a part of the Mt Gilead landscape and value the relationships we have built with our patrons over time.
What Makes Us Special
A Focus on Quality and Consistency: We believe that the best food comes from a dedication to the basics. By focusing on tried-and-true recipes, we ensure that every item served meets a standard of quality that our customers have come to expect and rely on.
A Welcoming Community Atmosphere: Our cafe is designed to be a comfortable retreat from the bustle of daily life. With a layout that encourages relaxation, it is the perfect spot to catch up with friends, finish a book, or simply enjoy a moment of solitude.
Convenient Location for Travelers and Locals: Positioned conveniently on OH-95, we are easily accessible for those commuting through Mt Gilead or for locals looking for a nearby spot to grab a bite. Our location makes us a natural choice for a quick stop or a longer, leisurely visit.
Dedicated Service: We prioritize the human element of hospitality. Our staff is committed to creating a positive experience for every guest, ensuring that you feel welcomed from the moment you walk through our doors until you head back out into your day.
At 8 Sisters Bakery Cafe, we are constantly mindful of the role we play in our guests' daily routines. We know that your time is valuable, and we appreciate that you choose to spend a portion of it with us. Our approach to service is simple: we treat every guest with respect and provide a clean, pleasant environment where you can enjoy your food without distraction. We are not interested in trends or complex gimmicks; instead, we focus on the fundamentals of good service and honest food preparation. This dedication to the core values of a neighborhood cafe is what defines our identity and keeps us motivated to serve the Mt Gilead community every single day.
As we look toward the future, our goal remains the same: to be a reliable, friendly, and high-quality establishment that you can count on. We invite you to visit us at 6200 OH-95 #300 to experience the atmosphere for yourself. Whether you are a long-time regular or a first-time visitor passing through Ohio, we look forward to greeting you and providing a pleasant experience. Thank you for supporting local businesses and for being a part of the story of 8 Sisters Bakery Cafe. We are proud to serve this community and look forward to seeing you soon.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Service options
Drive-through
In-store shopping
Onsite services
Takeout
Delivery
Offerings
Coffee
Dining options
Breakfast
Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Free Wi-Fi
Planning
Quick visit
Payments
Checks
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Menus
Photos
Reviews 8 Sisters Bakery Cafe
Teresa S.
05-04-2026
We stopped while traveling through Ohio at 8 Sisters Bakery, and wow, what a pleasant surprise!
We had the chicken salad croissant, coffee, and a chocolate cake doughnut! We had to split the croissant (they DID NOT skimp on the chicken salad!). It was delicious! The doughnut was scrumptious and a perfect accompaniment for the coffee! We sat outside at the little tables at the storefront. The ladies were more than helpful to us. A 10/10!
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Chicken Salad
Maisy McClellan
05-04-2026
Amazing! Some of the best donuts and breakfast I’ve had! I’m about to eat way too much.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Amit Patel
05-04-2026
This is the reason why you need to shop/dine at local establishments! It begins with the friendly staff who'll help you find that perfect treat! The donuts and the hand pies .. a great selection with various fruits and toppings, and they do take special orders for larger pies (my favorite is Key Lime pie) More
Ann Norton
05-04-2026
Stopped in first time ever picked up a maple cream sticks wow oh wow this is a gem. Over stuffed lots of maple icing fluffy cream soft donut. A real treat. This is a 10/10 donut. Not to sweet. This place is a new personal favorite ! More
Maisy McClellan
05-04-2026
Amazing! Some of the best donuts and breakfast I’ve had! I’m about to eat way too much.
Food: …
More
Jessie Gal-Chis
05-04-2026
8 Sisters Bakery made our wedding cake & sheet cakes for guests. All the flavors were absolutely delicious! All the members of the staff were kind & easy to communicate with—and the cake tasting was a fun experience! Highly recommend!
Chris Kobe
05-04-2026
Phenomenal food. You can tell the love and care put into the food! The baked goods are some of the best I’ve had in a while. Definitely less options as the morning goes on but that’s a testament to the quality
Meal type
Breakfast
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5
William Akers
05-04-2026
Place is great for get and go type of ppl. Not really a place to gather and hang out . Many wonderful baked goods pies and cupcakes . But there long John doughnuts maple with bacon ... hit it just hits . Pure joy eatting this doughnut for me ! 10 out of 10. I mean can ya tell i like it ?
Order type
Take out
Meal type
Breakfast
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 2
German
05-04-2026
The story alone of how this place got started is worth the visit. I ordered the club sandwich. It was full of meat and flavor. But, if you have a taste for donuts, get in early because they run out quickly. Blueberry cake is our favorite, and it sure was tasty.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5
Michael Thomas
05-04-2026
Not sure how this place has good reviews, let alone in business at all. Absolutely awful experience! I ordered the sandwich lunch special which was a Cuban and it was below average at best. The bread was a tasteless and the it looked like it was assembled by a child. Also ordered multiple donuts (apparently it’s a bakery first) to give them a shot. Also terrible. The donuts were hard, possibly stale, and had no taste. It was more of a dinner roll consistency and taste than a donut. Also it was $3.99 for a single donut!! If you charge a premium, it has to be at least average. Had high hopes going in, but completely disappointed and will not be back.
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 1
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 2
Noise level
Quiet, easy to talk
Heather Chapman
05-04-2026
First time here yesterday and new mt gilead member. I got the pull apart apple and 2 fry pies, one lemon(which i have not eaten as of yet)and one berry(which my son ate). The apple pull apart is amazing! I warmed mine up. The rolls they use go perfectly with the apple topping. My son said the berry pie wasn't overly sweet and very good. Cant wait to go back and try the chocolate bread
Food: 5
Ryan Davis
05-04-2026
Grabbed breakfast and donuts here the other day. Everything was really good. I ordered an English Sunrise Sandwich and a half dozen donuts. … More
Dmytro Buldakov
05-04-2026
Good selection of food and pastry with quite a reasonable price.
I got biscuits and gravy, it was delicious. Most places nowadays tend to … More
Heather Brooke-Ryan
05-04-2026
Food (4/5): this bakery has so many baked goods to choose from. They all look delicious. We tried many different things such as strawberry pie, sugar cookies, blueberry cake donut, jelly filled donut, cream filled donuts, etc. Some we liked … More
Thomas Kemmett
05-04-2026
What a fantastic little gem. The food is wonderful. The store smells like heaven. The bread is beautiful. Lots of bacon on the blt. It's worth going out of your way to grab a sandwich or pastry here. More
Joe Merriman
05-04-2026
This place is absolutely amazing! These are the best baked goods I have had in over 25 years. Drove about 30 minutes to try them out. Worth the drive! More
Annette Meade
05-04-2026
Hazelnut coffee was made fresh, the Bavarian cream donut with bacon on top was fabulous, and the Buckeye cheesecake brownie was wonderful! The hot honey chicken sandwich was delightful!!! The young lady with pink hair at the coffee station … More
Sandra Archibald
05-04-2026
Traveling across country and was looking for a good, local coffee place along our route. I couldn't be happier or more impressed! I got my husband the decadent signature coffee and I got the white mocha. EXCELLENT! … More
Garrett R.
05-04-2026
Stopped by for the donuts - fresh and big. Store is bright and clean, so was bathrooms and parking lot. Ordered some sandwiches to go, by the time we finished a donut our food was ready. More
Nova Terra
05-04-2026
As a convenient and charming stop right off the highway, this bakery is a delightful find. We enjoyed their delicious Thai mango iced tea and cherry limeade, along with perfectly baked scones and a wonderful fried pie. The cute signs inside and the option to sit outside make it a perfect place to take a break and enjoy a treat. More
Sweet Sinay's Reviews
05-04-2026
You often here about small town values and small town quality. 8 Sisters lives up to the reputation. … More
Reviews 8 Sisters Bakery Cafe