Located at 3050 Matson St, Chesterton, IN 46304, United States, Aj's Pizza Co serves as a welcoming destination for those who appreciate the timeless appeal of a well-crafted pizza. Our establishment is built on the belief that great food begins with quality ingredients and a commitment to traditional preparation methods. Whether you are a local resident looking for a reliable spot for a family dinner or a visitor passing through the Chesterton area, we invite you to experience a menu designed to satisfy a variety of tastes.
At Aj's Pizza Co, we understand that pizza is more than just a quick meal; it is a centerpiece for social gatherings and shared moments. Our kitchen team focuses on consistency and flavor, ensuring that every pie that leaves our oven meets our standards for quality. We take pride in being a part of the Chesterton community and strive to provide a comfortable environment where guests can relax and enjoy their meal without unnecessary distractions.
What Sets Our Kitchen Apart
We believe that the secret to a memorable dining experience lies in the details. While we keep our approach straightforward, we emphasize several core principles that define who we are and how we operate:
Commitment to Quality Ingredients: We prioritize sourcing reliable components for our dough, sauces, and toppings. By focusing on the fundamentals, we ensure that every bite reflects our dedication to the craft of pizza making.
A Welcoming Atmosphere: Our location on Matson St is designed to be an accessible space for everyone. We aim to foster a friendly environment where neighbors can connect and enjoy a meal in a relaxed setting.
Consistency in Every Order: We understand that our guests value reliability. Our team works diligently to maintain high standards across our entire menu, ensuring that your experience is consistently enjoyable every time you visit.
Community-Focused Service: Being situated in the heart of Chesterton, we view our restaurant as an extension of the local neighborhood. We value the relationships we build with our patrons and appreciate the opportunity to serve the community daily.
Our process is rooted in the idea that simplicity often yields the best results. By avoiding unnecessary complexity, we allow the quality of our ingredients to take center stage. We believe that a great pizza should be approachable, satisfying, and prepared with care, which is why we continue to refine our techniques while staying true to the classic styles that our guests have come to expect.
A Neighborhood Destination
Choosing where to eat is often about finding a place that feels right. At Aj's Pizza Co, we aim to be that reliable choice for the Chesterton community. We recognize that our guests have many options, and we are grateful for the support of those who choose to spend their time with us. Our goal is to continue providing a space where the focus remains on good food and the simple pleasure of sharing a meal with friends and family.
We invite you to visit us at 3050 Matson St to see what we are all about. Whether you are planning a casual evening out or simply craving a classic pizza, our team is ready to welcome you. We look forward to serving you and contributing to the vibrant culinary landscape of Chesterton, Indiana. Thank you for considering Aj's Pizza Co for your next meal, and we hope to see you at our table soon.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
From the business
Identifies as women-owned
Service options
Outdoor seating
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Serves local specialty
Sports
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Hard liquor
Late-night food
Private dining room
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegan options
Wine
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Free Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy
Crowd
College students
Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Good for kids birthday
High chairs
Kids' menu
Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Usually plenty of parking
Menus
Photos
Reviews Aj's Pizza Co
Max Kincheloe
05-04-2026
Pizza was good. Arguably a little undercooked. I’d recommend that you ask for yours extra crispy.
Salad was basic, the croutons were mid. For sure came out of some kind of packaging. They were tiny which was kinda cute tho.
The chocolate cake was actually really good tho. Like to die for good.
Our waiter was what made this review 5 starts. Fantastic service. Casey took the time to get to know us. That was awesome.
Renee Thorn
05-04-2026
Service was Extremely slow, waited 10 min before being seated in an empty dining area. Ordered Dr Pepper received Root Beer. My husband sat with an empty glass more than 3/4 of the meal. Garlic Cheese Bread - Yummy. House Pizza - delicious. Italian Lemon Cream Cake - mmmmmm More
Mo Johnson
05-04-2026
Whenever we travel to Illinois or Indiana, we will always stop here to eat. This is the best pizza ever. We've lived in Illinois, Indiana, Minnesota and now Ohio. Nothing beats AJ's. It doesn't matter how you like your pizza, AJ's has a … More
Becky D.
05-04-2026
AJ’s has the best pizza in NW Indiana, hands down! I usually get take out but the dining atmosphere is wonderful there. Staff is all very friendly whether it’s takeout or dine in. More
April Mccormack
05-04-2026
They have the best breadsticks and pizza around. I’ve been going there for many years. I’ve just been trying to get them to make a macaroni and cheese, candid, bacon, and candied jalapeño pizza. Hopefully they will come through for me❤️ More
Ashley Noojin
05-04-2026
The Dijon steak sandwich is amazing. My husband loves the garlic steak sandwich. So much flavor & always done right! More
Christian Mattix
05-04-2026
A wonderful “home town” pizza place in an upgraded location. Very friendly waitstaff. They have the usual pizza place offerings with a fantastic craft beer selection and delicious gluten free crust option. More
Lorie Chambers
05-04-2026
OMG. This place is amazing !!! There was nothing we got that was not exceptional. Fabulous flavors in their beef. I got the Garlic steak, Hubby got the Italian combo, and the BBQ mac n cheese. Plus we grabbed a Pizza to go. our bread twist … More
Bren Spaulding
05-04-2026
great pizza, bread twists were fantastic as well. service was nice and we didn’t wait too long. everything was clean and a good atmosphere. More
Trish Unger
05-04-2026
I ordered a gluten free pizza. It arrived and the crust was burned. My husband ordered an Italian beef sandwich. It had hardly any beef and no cheese at all. Very disappointing. Probably won’t be back. More
DebiZ
05-04-2026
I ordered the Agrula Bararta salad with the lemon basil vinegrette, 6 inch smoked ham sandwich with red sauce on the side and 8 mild chicken wings bone in with Ranch on the side. Everything was tasty. I would have given a 5 for food but … More
Jennifer Bottari
05-04-2026
We had delivery and our food was delivered 22 minutes ahead of schedule which is awesome! Food was hot and great quality, ohh and taste is/ was Delicious! This was our 1st time getting food from AJ's, and it was a Great 1st time experience. Thanks AJs 😁 … More
Max Kincheloe
05-04-2026
Pizza was good. Arguably a little undercooked. I’d recommend that you ask for yours extra crispy. … More
Bruce Pritz
05-04-2026
In my neverending quest to find the perfect pizza I tried a place I have not been to before, and while I realize that taste is subjective to an individuals taste I believe that there are factors that all can agree on, such as , quality of … More
Angel Montúfar
05-04-2026
Really great experience! Excited to come again and again!
The service is the reason for 5 stars. Casey was incredible. She was attentive … More
Andy Walters
05-04-2026
I've dined in and ordered from AJ's a lot over the past couple of years and it always tastes great! As a non-native to Chesteron, it has become one of my favorite places to eat when I visit, which usually includes a cheese and veggie pizza, … More
Jennifer Jendrzejczyk
05-04-2026
Dine in on a busy Friday night. We ordered a dinner salad, perfect portion, bruschetta, it was fresh and delicious, and a small pizza, well done. It was exactly as ordered. Our server was available but not pesky. We are part of the AJs … More
Marissa Lee
05-04-2026
Ordered the gluten free pizza, Mac n cheese and cheesecake as a pickup order. Everything tasted great especially the gluten free pizza! Food was warm and ready at pickup time. Easy location to find. More
Ben Crandall
05-04-2026
Everything here was great. Service was phenomenal. Waitress knew the menu, made recommendations and was on top of service. Cesar salad was excellent. Waitress mentioned they made their own Cesar dressing. It was great, a lot thicker than … More
Devin Klewer
05-04-2026
It was amazing!! I loved the pizza, the sauce was great, and the crust was nice and crunchy. The waitress was nice, was patient, and we got our food super fast. The vibe was cool, and the television was good for when I was waiting. Overall amazing place. More
Melissa Swank
05-04-2026
My 1st visit & everything was amazing. Service was on point & friendly. Food was delicious we had appetizers & pizzas. We will be back More
Reviews Aj's Pizza Co