Nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, Bay Ridge Pizza has established itself as a cornerstone of the local culinary landscape. Located at 7704 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, this establishment serves as a gathering place for residents and visitors alike who appreciate the timeless appeal of a well-crafted pie. The atmosphere is defined by a commitment to the neighborhood, offering a space where the community can come together over shared meals and the simple, honest pleasure of traditional pizza making.
The philosophy behind the kitchen is rooted in consistency and quality. By focusing on the fundamentals of dough, sauce, and cheese, the team at Bay Ridge Pizza ensures that every order reflects a dedication to the craft. Whether you are stopping by for a quick slice during a busy afternoon or sitting down for a full meal with family and friends, the experience is designed to be welcoming and unpretentious. It is this focus on the basics that has allowed the restaurant to remain a staple on 5th Avenue for years, weathering the changing tides of the city while maintaining its identity as a reliable neighborhood favorite.
The interior reflects the character of Brooklyn, blending a casual, no-frills aesthetic with the warmth of a neighborhood institution. It is the kind of place where the staff knows the regulars by name and where the aroma of baking crust greets you the moment you step through the door. For those living in or passing through this part of New York, Bay Ridge Pizza represents more than just a place to eat; it is a reflection of the local culture and the enduring popularity of classic American-style pizza.
What Sets Bay Ridge Pizza Apart
Commitment to Traditional Techniques: The kitchen prioritizes time-honored methods of preparation, ensuring that the dough is handled with care and the ingredients are balanced to create a harmonious flavor profile in every bite.
A Neighborhood Focal Point: Situated conveniently on 5th Avenue, the restaurant serves as a hub for the local community, providing a consistent and familiar environment for neighbors to connect and enjoy a meal together.
Focus on Quality Ingredients: By sourcing reliable components for their recipes, the team maintains a standard of quality that keeps patrons returning, emphasizing the importance of fresh, simple elements in creating a superior product.
Authentic Brooklyn Atmosphere: The establishment captures the unique spirit of Bay Ridge, offering a dining experience that feels genuine, unhurried, and deeply connected to the history of the surrounding area.
A Culinary Staple in Brooklyn
In a city as vast and diverse as New York, finding a spot that feels like home is a rare and valuable experience. Bay Ridge Pizza manages to strike that balance by focusing on what truly matters: serving good food in a space that respects the community it serves. The dedication to maintaining a high standard of service and culinary integrity has solidified its reputation as a reliable destination for anyone craving a slice in the heart of Brooklyn.
As you explore the various offerings along 5th Avenue, you will find that this establishment stands out not through flashy gimmicks or trends, but through its steadfast commitment to its craft. It remains a testament to the idea that when you focus on quality and community, the results speak for themselves. Whether you are a long-time resident of the neighborhood or simply exploring the culinary map of Brooklyn, a visit to this local landmark offers a genuine taste of the area's character and a satisfying meal that honors the traditions of the trade.
Ultimately, the success of Bay Ridge Pizza is built on the loyalty of its patrons and the hard work of those behind the counter. By staying true to its roots and continuing to provide a welcoming environment, the restaurant ensures that it will remain a vital part of the 5th Avenue corridor for years to come. It is a simple, effective, and deeply satisfying part of the Brooklyn dining scene that invites everyone to pull up a chair and enjoy a slice of the neighborhood.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible seating
Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Serves local specialty
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Vegan options
Vegetarian options
Wine
Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Restroom
Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Quiet
Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safespace
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Menus
Photos
Reviews Bay Ridge Pizza
Lois
30-05-2026
I'm very happy with this broccoli pizza, the food is light in taste, healthier. Comfortable and clean dining environment with friendly attitude. More
Evelyn Maria Gonzalez
30-05-2026
Great mozzarella sticks! The trip to BROOKLYN from JERSEY with my son Ale was EVERYTHING! Bay Ridge Pizza’s pig in a blanket had a dough that just melts in your mouth; reminds you of a pastry but still gives you the kick of pork. And— I will NEVER have a SICILIAN SLICE in Jersey again!!! More
Martin Sunshine
30-05-2026
What a great New York pizzeria. I got the chicken and broccoli rabe with sun-dried tomatoes. The bread is so amazing and this is one of the tasty sandwiches I've ever had! More
Mimi Townes
30-05-2026
Very First time in New York the food was very delicious the people were professional and friendly definitely coming back to this spot. More
R D
30-05-2026
Late on the night of Sunday, December 18, 2022, my friends and I visited Bay Ridge Pizza after touring Christmas displays in Dyker Heights. Cold, hungry and in one case, unwell, Gaspar (the owner) and Christopher both welcomed us in for … More
Alexander Tkach
30-05-2026
Good pizza. Good place. It's an old school pizzeria without all of the frills of a fancy Italian place but pizza that would hold it's own in any competition. Friendly staff, friendly Owner. Good place to sit down after a long day and have slice and a beer. The vibes are great More
Elizabeth Miabella Marte
30-05-2026
Hello everyone , wouldn't recommend this place so much. I ordered chicken parm with ziti. I asked for garlic knots instead of bread, but they suggested we can put the same sauce on the bread, with no charge that didn't happen. I ask to … More
Steven Nechamkin
30-05-2026
The restaurant is located in the Bay Ridge section of Brooklyn. The Italian food was average. The pizza was O.K. Hero size is good. I ordered a fish entree with pasta. The fish and pasta came together in one tray with a tomato sauce. … More
Stefanie Maravegias
30-05-2026
Lived down the street from here 10 years ago and loved it. Just came back for vacation and it still slams hard! Best pizza around, do not miss it. More
Julie
30-05-2026
Pizza was delicious and Gaspar was so knowledgeable about Gluten free and cross contamination matters. They also have GF pasta. So happy we found this place. Our go-to pizza place More
Many Attitudes of Dennis
30-05-2026
SOLID slice, 4 out 5. It’s well balanced from tip to crust and nothing about it is wrong. With that said, for me, it does fall slightly short of just the extra special something. However, there’s enough here to make go in intending to only … More
Adéla Fastová
30-05-2026
delicious GLUTEN FREE options! staff very friendly and accommodating
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Wait time
No wait
Dietary restrictions
gluten free, celiac safe
Michael Thompson
30-05-2026
Gaspare really does make some of the best pizza in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn and New York! I had four different slices in one sitting. More
Rahul Khandke
30-05-2026
We ordered a grandma pie with broccoli rabe and vegan cheese. It was absolutely amazing, they don’t skimp on the sauce or cheese and the crust was perfectly thin but still so firm and crispy. We will be back! More
Grace Maple
30-05-2026
THIS IS THE BEST PIZZERIA IVE EVER BEEN TOO.
10/10 Recommend. 😋
Anything and everything you eat here is the best, the quality in every … More
Ryan Higgins
30-05-2026
This is the absolute best pizza in the state of New York. For all you out of towners that comes to New York and want the “Pizza” experience you need to come to Bay Ridge Pizza. They are The epitome of what New York pizza is. Staff is amazing and the owner is the best!!! More
F Haseq
30-05-2026
First time trying this place and really disappointed. I've had vodka slices in the past. I've had gluten free thin crust. And they all had taste and looked amazing. This was not it. No taste at all. Did not look appetizing one bit. Waste of $20. This is not a vodka pizza. I only had one slice and forced myself to eat it since I paid for it. It is so hard to look for a place that does GF thin crust vodka pizza. And the one place I found here was beyond disappointing. Covering the slices with all that mozzarella cheese? No thank you. And the sauce underneath had no taste. First and last time trying this place.
Food: 1
Robert JL Thompson
30-05-2026
Their gluten free pizza is fantastic. Perfect grease-to-crunch ratio. And it flops like Brooklyn pizza should. I had a Redbridge gf ale with that. I highly recommend. More
Adéla Fastová
30-05-2026
delicious GLUTEN FREE options! staff very friendly and accommodating
Order type…
More
Jennifer Jordan
30-05-2026
This place is one of our go to places. Everything is delicious and its always friendly, fast, clean. Yum. More
Christopher Myler
30-05-2026
Honestly, one of the grossest things I’ve eaten in the neighborhood. I had two “OK” experiences with this place, so today, I decided to try ordering online for delivery. … More
J R
30-05-2026
Ordered 2 gluten free pies. Delivery took an hour and a half. The pizzas were the size of my hand, the crust was too hard to chew and the sauce ridiculously hard. Completely inedible. These days, there is no excuse for gluten free food to … More
Carlos
30-05-2026
Bro.. I'm not even exaggerating. This has to be the best pizza I've ever had in my 31 years of life. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming. I'm a native new yorker. I've had my share of New York pizza. Bay Ridge Pizza takes the gold. My 5 stars are genuine. Highly recommend. More
Randi Oyervides
30-05-2026
First stop from JFK, it was truly the best. We ordered a mushroom Alfredo mini pizza and a gluten-free, black olive pizza and meatball roll and a single cheese slice. When I tell you that Alfredo straight from the pan 🤤. Everything was hot and fresh. Amazing host and good people. … More
Laura McKenna
30-05-2026
Stopped in for the first time for a quick slice while in the neighborhood when I saw they’d been in business since 1978. They had just brought out a tray of square pizza. I ordered a slice and it was so good, I got a second. I can’t speak for the other slices, but a half-mushroom, half-olive pizza fresh out of the oven looked delicious. I’ll be back!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Paula V
30-05-2026
This has to be the biggest joke of a pizza I’ve ever seen in my life. The cheese is not even on the damn pizza. is literally coming off, also the dough is raw. Absolute garbage. Shame on you for even thinking to send out such monumental crap .
Food: 1
Scott Miranda
30-05-2026
Cheese gluten free pizza rocked. My son has Celiac and this was cooked well. No gooey dough that some places struggle with cooking right.
Saw guy walking an order out to someone too. This place cares!
Great job everyone and thank you!
Order type
Take out
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
LittleCesar2000
30-05-2026
Came here a month ago first time, got a whole pizza siciliana with pepperoni. Its an old school pizza joint. So good and the kids of course loved it. They were super busy but cranked it out during peak dinner rush. Now I'm hungry just thinking about it.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Argy Samakovlis
30-05-2026
I always order catered food from Bay Ridge pizza for the holidays or for birthday parties. They never disappoint. Most recently yesterday for my daughter‘s birthday. All of my guests were asking where I got the food from because it was so delicious. One of the shrimp trays I got was phenomenal. The shrimp was huge and high-quality and so good. And their prices are very reasonable. I love this place!
Order type
Delivery
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Seating type
Booth seating
iam Toussaint
30-05-2026
I am very upset with this place, I ordered chicken ceaser salad and meatballs. First the chicken was not fresh tasted like leftovers. The meatballs wasn't fresh but no taste. I don't understand how you servings people those kind of food.
Order type
Delivery
Price per person
$30–40
Food: 1
Wait time
No wait
Cassie Maloney
30-05-2026
We’ve ordered a few times at work—delivery always quick and friendly! Yesterday I finally went into the shop and it’s just such a classic pizzeria vibe with amazing service. Growing up in Bensonhurst I know a thing or two about classic pizzerias! 😂
Fantastic regular slice! Thin and gooey and delicious. The potato croquettes are out of this world as well.
Great spot for a slice after a long day at work!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Reviews Bay Ridge Pizza