Discovering the Authentic Taste of Brooklyn Pickle in Raleigh
Nestled within the vibrant Marketplace at Lake Boone, Brooklyn Pickle Sandwich Shop has established itself as a welcoming destination for those who appreciate the art of a well-crafted sandwich. Located at 4025 Lake Boone Trail, Suite 120, in Raleigh, North Carolina, this establishment brings a touch of traditional deli culture to the local community. The shop focuses on providing a straightforward, satisfying dining experience where the quality of ingredients and the care put into preparation take center stage. Whether you are a local resident looking for a reliable lunch spot or a visitor exploring the culinary landscape of Raleigh, the shop offers a comfortable environment designed for both quick bites and relaxed meals.
The philosophy behind Brooklyn Pickle is rooted in the belief that a great sandwich starts with high-quality components. By prioritizing fresh produce, premium meats, and artisanal breads, the kitchen ensures that every order meets a consistent standard of excellence. The atmosphere is intentionally unpretentious, reflecting a commitment to genuine hospitality that makes guests feel at home from the moment they walk through the door. It is a place where the focus remains on the simple pleasure of a hearty meal served in a clean, efficient, and friendly setting.
Why Brooklyn Pickle Stands Out
Commitment to Quality Ingredients: Every sandwich is assembled using carefully sourced meats and fresh, crisp vegetables. The dedication to selecting the right components ensures that every bite delivers a balanced flavor profile that satisfies the palate.
A Welcoming Community Atmosphere: Situated in the heart of the Marketplace at Lake Boone, the shop serves as a gathering point for the neighborhood. The interior is designed to be accessible and comfortable, making it an ideal choice for a casual lunch break or a weekend outing with friends and family.
Consistency and Reliability: Guests return to Brooklyn Pickle because they know exactly what to expect: a well-prepared meal served with efficiency. The staff takes pride in maintaining high standards of service, ensuring that each visit is as pleasant as the last.
Thoughtful Preparation: Beyond just assembling ingredients, the team at Brooklyn Pickle understands the nuances of sandwich making. From the ratio of fillings to the texture of the bread, every detail is considered to provide a superior eating experience that stands apart from mass-produced alternatives.
The culinary landscape of Raleigh continues to evolve, yet there remains a timeless appeal to the classic sandwich shop. Brooklyn Pickle manages to honor this tradition while fitting perfectly into the modern lifestyle of the Lake Boone community. By focusing on the fundamentals—freshness, flavor, and friendly service—the shop has cultivated a loyal following of patrons who value substance over spectacle. It is not merely about the convenience of a sandwich; it is about the experience of enjoying a meal that has been prepared with genuine care and attention to detail.
As you navigate the various dining options in Raleigh, Brooklyn Pickle remains a standout choice for those who seek a reliable, high-quality meal. The combination of its convenient location at 4025 Lake Boone Trail and its unwavering commitment to deli-style excellence makes it a staple for anyone in the area. Whether you are stopping by for a quick lunch or planning a casual meal, the team looks forward to serving you and sharing their passion for great sandwiches. We invite you to visit us at the Marketplace at Lake Boone and discover why so many locals consider us their go-to spot for a satisfying and authentic dining experience.
Amenities and More
Menus
Pickles & Peppers
Brooklyn Full Sour Pickle$3.50
Quart Full Sour Pickles$8.95
Quart Dill Pickles$8.95
Whole Dill Pickle$3.50
Beverages
20 Oz Bottle (Water)$3.25
12 Oz Can (Soda)$2.50
Dr. Brown$3.25
Pure Leaf Teas (20 Oz)$3.25
20 Oz Bottle (Soda)$3.25
Chocolate Milk$3.95
Desserts & Snacks
Rice Pudding$5.45
NY Style Cheesecake$6.00
Homemade Brownie With Walnuts$3.45
Chocolate Pudding$5.45
Homemade Cream Cheese Brownie$4.25
NY Style Cheesecake With Cherries$6.95
Dirty Chips (Small, 2.0 Oz)$3.50
Jumbo Cookies$3.35
Black And White Cookie$4.45
Homemade Banana Pudding$5.95
Dirty Chips (Large, 4.75 Oz)$5.75
Fresh Salads & Homemade Sides
Homemade Macaroni Salad$3.75
Chicken Caesar$11.95
Homemade Potato Salad$3.75
Homemade Coleslaw$3.75
Brooklyn Cobb Salad$13.95
Potato Knish$4.50
Add A Scoop (Chicken, Tuna Or Egg Salad)$5.25
Homemade Broccoli Salad$3.75
Homemade Pasta Salad$3.75
Brooklyn Club Salad$11.95
Garden Salad$8.95
Giant 12" Subs (Whole or Half)
Brooklyn Pickle Special Sub$10.95
Capocollo Sub$10.95
Hard Salami Sub$10.95
Egg & Olive Sub$9.95
Chicken Salad Sub$10.95
Liverwurst Sub$8.95
Turkey Breast Sub$10.95
Meatball On 8" Roll$11.95
Ham-Bone Sub (Ham, Turkey & Swiss)$10.95
Italian Sub W/Italian Tomatoes$10.95
Corned Beef Sub$10.95
Tuna Salad Sub$9.95
Cheese Sub$8.95
Veggie Sub$8.95
Pastrami Sub$10.95
Bologna Sub$8.95
Roast Pork Sub$10.95
Roast Beef Sub$10.95
Ham & Cheese Sub$9.95
BLT Sub$10.95
Giant Sandwiches (Whole or Half)
Bologna$9.95
Veggie$9.95
Turkey Breast$11.95
Capocollo$11.95
Roast Beef$11.95
Turkey Club With Bacon$14.50
Pastrami$11.95
Hard Salami$11.95
Roast Pork$11.95
BLT$11.95
Ham-Bone (Ham, Turkey & Swiss)$11.95
Egg & Olive$10.95
Ham & Cheese$10.95
Chicken Salad$11.95
Italian W/Italian Tomatoes$11.95
Cheese$9.95
Corned Beef$11.95
The BP Reuben (Heated)$12.95
Brooklyn Pickle Special$11.95
Tuna Salad$10.95
The BP Cuban (Heated)$11.95
PB & J$6.00
Liverwurst$9.95
Homemade Soups & Daily Hot Special
Homemade Chicken Noodle$5.95
Seasonal Soup$5.95
Hot Daily Chef's Special$6.45
Homemade Chili$5.95
Matzo Ball Soup (Bowl) - Raleigh Only$8.95
Reviews Brooklyn Pickle Sandwich Shop
Becca Walawender
30-05-2026
I'm a central NY native and a huge Brooklyn Pickle fan! The Raleigh location did not disappoint! Same vibe. Same high quality ingredients. Same awesome experience! We introduced our friends from Durham to the yumminess and they're hooked now too. Now I just need one to open in Prince George's County Maryland so I don't need to travel so far for my favorite sandwich!
Order type
Dine in
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Group size
Suitable for all group sizes
Aaron Phillips
30-05-2026
Decent...wish they had Jewish rye for the pastrami sandwich, dark rye doesn't have the carraway seeds. Pastrami and deli nustard was good, bread was a bit soggy though. The matzo ball soup was good- matzo ball was tasty and as expected, … More
Nicomi Kloempken
30-05-2026
Menu isn't too complicated, but DELICIOUS. My first visit...the cashier was very helpful, and the lady making my sandwich was excellent. They have the good, crisp dill pickles! The bread is super fresh, tender, beautiful texture and tastes just wonderful. More
Victor Lasher
30-05-2026
Brooklyn Pickle – A Deli Sandwich Lover’s Dream in Raleigh, NC!
During my recent trip to Raleigh, I had the pleasure of visiting Brooklyn … More
Lynne Hildreth
30-05-2026
We go out of our way to drive from North Hills area to Brooklyn Pickle. The sandwiches are great (and huge!) - my teens love the pastrami in particular. The pickles, as you would hope, are fantastic too. Glad we discovered it! Only … More
Stephen Brown
30-05-2026
Delicious sandwiches! I was in the area and came here on a whim... I'll be making trips back here for sure.
The bread is really good, the sandwiches are huge, and the soup was perfect for this cold rainy day.
I had the Brooklyn Pickle Special and cream tomato soup - both were fantastic. The corned beef was excellent so I'll be sure to come back soon and try the Reuben next
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Recommended dishes
Zac Barres
30-05-2026
Being from Syracuse and moving here to Raleigh 6 years ago, and eating at Brooklyn Pickle my whole life, I was excited that Raleigh would be getting a store.. When the location first opened I was getting food atleast once every every 2 weeks. The service was great and the food was as good as always. But I have to say that the last few months the place has fallen apart. I’ve recommended BP to countless people in the area and multiple people have said the same thing. They loved it at first but have since stopped going. Last week a friend texted me “won’t be going to Brooklyn Pickle again” and he explained to me how his bread was ripped apart and everything was just thrown on the sandwich. He also said how impatient and annoyed the workers were.. So I went in recently and got two sandwiches. The employee didn’t only seem impatient, (they) were straight up rude. The order was very simple but (they) rolled their eyes when we asked questions and wanted something added to our order. Not only that but our food was thrown together with no care at all. No one forced them to take that job but atleast try to do good while you’re working. Retraining needs to be done or I can see this store not lasting long. I hate that it’s happening because I have loved BP for so long.
Order type
Take out
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 3
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 2
Group size
2 people
Katie Smith
30-05-2026
Ordered online for pick up tonight and it was seamless. We got just what we asked for even with what we wanted on one half, and not on the other. The sandwiches are so good and the bread here is heaven. Just heaven. Go. Eat here now if you haven’t. You will not be disappointed.
Order type
Take out
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Group size
2 people
Keri Banegas
30-05-2026
They make a decent sammie with some delicious meats and toppings! That's the winner for sure, hands down. Tried some of the sides.... and the potato salad was good, the pasta salad was just alright, and the knish was awful. They nuked it before they put it through the griller and it essentially made it inedible. I couldn't even bite the edges since they were hard as a rock. I couldn't even cut into the middle of it. I finally just ripped open the middle to try the filling and it was okay. Simply put, have a sammie and leave it at that. I didn't try the soups or the riggies yet but maybe I'll try again the next time we're in the mood for a rueby. Oh and the staff were all friendly, which is a nice bonus.
Edit for the owner's comment: that's so sweet to offer a replacement, but unnecessary! Now that you say the bit about overcooked, that's likely what happened, especially with the one side being burnt black. It happens, I'm sure it's not indicative of the standard experience. And it definitely won't keep me from coming back by any means!
Order type
Dine in
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Noise level
Quiet, easy to talk
Group size
Suitable for all group sizes
Stephgar
30-05-2026
Finally, a place that makes a sandwich like I would at home!!
Ordered the giant corned beef on rye with Russian dressing and sauerkraut. Absolutely the freshest sandwich I’ve had in a long time. The bread melted in your mouth. The meat portion is outstanding. Hard to find a place that gives you that big of a portion. The flavor was fantastic. I will definitely be back to try the rest of the menu.
Order type
Delivery
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Joe
30-05-2026
Was given a caesar salad that was dates for expiration today, 3/9, and lettuce was visibly browned. Not what I was expecting from a sub shop claiming to usw the freshest ingredients. Needless to say I won’t be eating it so it’s a waste of … More
Sierra Johnson
30-05-2026
Tiara is so great at this location! Our favorite spot to go for lunchtime. ‘The Cuban’ is our favorite meal! More
Sue Overka
30-05-2026
They Ruben’s here are amazing. The meat is just so high-quality and the people are awesome and super cool!! The subs are great too! Potato salad is awesome! I love the atmosphere! Thank you More
francine pirozzoli
30-05-2026
If you’re looking for a Italian deli/want the taste of that, this place ain’t it. The subs taste like hot dog buns. However, if you’re looking for a deli that feels/taste like you’re going to a baseball game this would be the perfect place! More
Nancy Maltais
30-05-2026
Came here today for lunch. I got a 1/2 BLT and a side order of the homemade potato salad. My husband got the 1/2 Cuban with a side of pasta salad. Both were really excellent and we can’t wait to come back. We noticed the employees kept the prep area very clean and changed their gloves frequently which we appreciate. More
Willie Smith
30-05-2026
The first time I went, I got a beautiful pastrami & corn beef sandwich on rye. The 2nd time I went it was an Italian that was so/so and this 3rd and last time was a roast beef hero with tomato & mayo. It has one pore of roast beef folded in … More
Joyone Farmer
30-05-2026
Actually I door dashed a meal from here today. Food was so good I had to give a google review. My order was a bowl of chicken noodle soup, half chicken salad sandwich on white, with tomato and a slice of provolone. One pickle as well. … More
Dena LaRocca
30-05-2026
Great deli with super friendly staff. Bread and all the ingredients were very fresh. Loved that they had a variety of chips to go with our choices and that they had Dr Brown sodas. They had a deli fridge stocked full off salads, desserts, … More
Deja'h Brown
30-05-2026
We placed a catering order for our fall event at work. The manger was very nice and took the time to explain how their catering process works to my coworker. It was a very stress free experience. The sandwiches and sides (pasta salad, … More
Jonathan Davis
30-05-2026
I love how they prepared my Food at this Restaurant. I got a Whole Pastrami Sandwich and a Half Reuben. My Pastrami Sandwich was delicious, it had plenty of Pastrami and was topped just right. I definitely will eat here again.!! More
Reviews Brooklyn Pickle Sandwich Shop