Located at 453 Chestnut St, Oneonta, NY 13820, Jay's Place serves as a welcoming destination for those seeking a genuine dining experience in the heart of New York. Our establishment is built on the foundation of providing a comfortable environment where community members, students, and visitors alike can gather to enjoy well-prepared meals. We believe that the essence of a great restaurant lies in the balance between a relaxed atmosphere and a commitment to quality ingredients, ensuring that every guest feels right at home from the moment they step through our doors.
Our philosophy is simple: we focus on the fundamentals of hospitality. By maintaining a consistent approach to our service and our kitchen operations, we strive to create a space that feels like a neighborhood staple. Whether you are stopping by for a quick bite during a busy workday or settling in for a longer meal with friends and family, our team is dedicated to providing a pleasant and memorable experience. We take pride in being part of the Oneonta community and look forward to serving you with the care and attention that our patrons have come to expect.
What Makes Our Restaurant Unique
At Jay's Place, we prioritize the elements that contribute to a satisfying dining experience. While we keep our menu focused and approachable, we pay close attention to the details that matter most to our guests. Here are a few reasons why people choose to dine with us:
A Welcoming Atmosphere: We have designed our space to be inviting and comfortable, making it an ideal setting for casual conversations, small group gatherings, or a quiet meal alone. Our interior reflects a classic, unpretentious style that allows the focus to remain on the company you keep and the food on your plate.
Commitment to Quality: We source our ingredients with care, ensuring that every dish we prepare meets a high standard of freshness and flavor. By focusing on reliable preparation methods, we aim to provide consistent quality that keeps our guests coming back time and time again.
Community-Centric Location: Situated conveniently on Chestnut Street, we are easily accessible to those living in or visiting Oneonta. Being part of this vibrant area allows us to connect with a diverse range of people, which is a core part of what makes running our restaurant so rewarding.
Attentive Service: Our staff is trained to provide friendly and efficient service. We understand that your time is valuable, and we strive to balance a relaxed dining pace with the attentiveness required to ensure your needs are met throughout your visit.
A Neighborhood Destination
The landscape of dining in Oneonta is diverse, and we are proud to contribute our own unique character to the local scene. At Jay's Place, we do not try to be everything to everyone; instead, we focus on being a reliable, high-quality option for those who appreciate good food served in a friendly setting. We invite you to visit us at 453 Chestnut St to see for yourself why so many locals consider us a go-to spot for their dining needs.
We are constantly looking for ways to improve and refine our offerings while staying true to the values that established our reputation. Your feedback is always welcome, as it helps us grow and continue to serve the Oneonta community effectively. We look forward to welcoming you to our table soon and sharing a meal that reflects our passion for hospitality and our dedication to the craft of cooking. Thank you for considering Jay's Place for your next dining occasion.
Amenities and More
Menus
Photos
Reviews Jay's Place
Kate W
30-05-2026
We are thankful we did not get sick. We both ordered steak (sirloin and mignon tips.) They sat in an unusual liquid which was pooling under them.. questionable. They were clearly frozen and we aren’t sure how well they were stored before … More
Amanda Travis
30-05-2026
Pay the extra and get yourself the bacon garlic bleu cheese addition!!
Order type…
More
Edna Tompkins
30-05-2026
Fantastic food, nice waitress ,had a great time there
Order type
Dine in…
More
Derek Vannier
30-05-2026
Food and waitstaff are both excellent. The place itself could use a refresh.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 3
Amanda Travis
30-05-2026
Pay the extra and get yourself the bacon garlic bleu cheese addition!!
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Steak, French Onion Soup
Edna Tompkins
30-05-2026
Fantastic food, nice waitress ,had a great time there
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$100+
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
French Onion Soup, Steak, Seafood Pasta, Dill Pickle Wings, Surf and Turf Sreak and Lobster
Matt
30-05-2026
Food was bland at least my meal was( haddock)... after a few bites I pulled a long hair out of my meal, that meal was taken off the bill but nothing more done to make the experience satisfying, felt like a complete waste of time driving an … More
Ken Gurian
30-05-2026
I ordered the French onion soup and prime ribs. Both were very good! I would definitely order them again. The salad with lemon pepper dressing was excellent as well. … More
Brian Sisk
30-05-2026
Fantastic!!! I live 2 hrs away and always look forward to dinner at Jay's. The service is very good. Atmosphere is very nice. The food is extremely good. Prices are fair. I highly recommend!!! If you skip the nachos YOUR A FOOL... just saying...
Christina Gallagher
30-05-2026
Dinner and dessert were absolutely amazing, the staff is very friendly, and our waitress was very attentive. Looking forward to going back. More
Patty Phelan
30-05-2026
This place is hidden off the road, but it is worth finding. There were five of us, and we all loved our meals. Portions were very generous, but most importantly, the flavors were on point. We will definitely dine here again on our next visit to Oneonta. More
Community Watchdog
30-05-2026
Dam the food did taste as good as the pictures!
Food: 5…
More
Donna Sue
30-05-2026
I am very fussy about my food and service when I go out to eat. I am not easy to please and I am thrilled to say that this place is an absolute treasure. We enjoyed our dining experience so much. We had our company Christmas party here and … More
Lisa Meschutt
30-05-2026
I’ve been going to Jay’s Place for many years, it’s a favorite! I love the small but varied menu, it’s not overwhelming. The chef is amazing and will make anything from their previous menus or specials if you ask (and he has the … More
Debra Heim
30-05-2026
Jays place is one of local favorites! The service is always on point(love Angie as our server), but everyone is great! Food is always amazing and delicious and the atmosphere is always warm and welcoming. More
William Copeland
30-05-2026
Food was excellent. Party had 2 strip steak dinners and a scallop dinner. Meat was perfectly cooked. Only mistake was Cajun seasoning was accidentally left off but cook realized and sent some out. Scallops were cooked in honey and butter … More
Community Watchdog
30-05-2026
Dam the food did taste as good as the pictures!
Food: 5
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 4
Annie W
30-05-2026
Great food, awesome staff, always a great experience at Jay's Place!
Scott Soultung
30-05-2026
So once again Sal and I hit a new establishment and we not disappointed!! From the start the drinks we're rocking and the appetizers we're hitting! We had the special Chicken Cordon Blue and they they were God damn amazing tasty hot and fresh and the sauce was straight fire ! Our waitress Amy was the best so happy and upbeat and beyond attentive!! So all in all we will be back soon for shizzle!!
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Reservation
Reservations recommended
Special events
Not sure
Seating type
Indoor dining area
Mike Makofske
30-05-2026
Had a Saturday nite Prime rib dinner, and it was awful.
Appearance was nice, but meat was tuff, un cuttable, and not chewable.
The waitress did not charge me for the meal though.
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 1
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 2
Reservation
Reservations recommended
Ronald Marsh
30-05-2026
we had a retirement party there. the staff was more than accommodating. smiling and interacting with our group. the food came out relatively quick. best part was our group if 11 people all received our food within minutes of each other. I would say within 5 minutes the whole group had their food. the food was spot on and the staff was happy to make special requests. for me the calamari app was great . the peperoncini peppers were a great touch. my prime rib was just as ordered and another guest suggested getting it Baltimore style. I was not disappointed. would highly recommend this restaurant. make reservations especially on the weekend.
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Noise level
Moderate noise
Wait time
No wait
Seating type
Indoor dining area
Breanna A
30-05-2026
Excellent service. Excellent food. Consistent quality. I have been dining here for years. Highly recommended place to dine in for dinner in Oneonta.
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$30–50
PHILLFS
30-05-2026
Place is top notch ! Greatly prepared food with very friendly service !!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Ivan Burton
30-05-2026
Excellent food, courteous staff, good prices.
Janet Spadavecchia
30-05-2026
I have this establishment a try based on this reviews from a colleague. I ordered the seared tuna entree special with pineapple ginger soy sauce (cooked to your preference of doneness). I ordered it to be cooked rare and I also asked for the French onion soup. The French onion soup was delicious - rich broth, a generous helping of onions, French bread included within, and topped off with a layer of cheese. The tuna arrived overdone and my colleague's also complained of the same problem. The Entree was underwhelming both in taste and consistency, so I don't plan on ordering it again. Wait staff are friendly and attentive.
Amanda R
30-05-2026
We had a great experience here! The server, Peggy, was amazing. Kept our drinks refreshed before we even realized we needed them, very friendly and attentive, even packaged our leftovers for us! The food was amazing, huge portions. Biggest stuffed mushrooms I've had! Would eat here again and recommend to anyone!
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Keiya K
30-05-2026
Visited this gem during a short trip and 1000% recommend. The food was so fresh, everything was delicious. My son and my dad had the nachos for appetizer, I had fried green tomatoes, my kiddo had a burger and fries, my dad had French onion soup and Baltimore surf and turf . . . All delicious!!! I also had clam chowder and the surf and turf. So much food, plenty leftover and everything was so good.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Hilda Torres
30-05-2026
Good food, everyone is nice. Had the best waiter 🤗 …
Bruce Trimble
30-05-2026
What a wonderfully delicious meal! The New England clam chowder was the best I’ve ever had and the Baltimore scallops were divine. Celeste is the best! More
M Duke
30-05-2026
Very good sirloin steak grilled to perfection. Excellent wait staff and atmosphere.
Price per person…
More
greg otte
30-05-2026
Interesting little place don't miss it. Good menu and great specials. Amazing fresh made bread.
Ord…
More
Derek Vannier
30-05-2026
Food and waitstaff are both excellent. The place itself could use a refresh.
Food: 5…
More
Tim Mclaughlin
30-05-2026
Stopped in without a reservation and was seated quickly. The staff is very friendly, and the food is very good. Will definitely be back.
Jeanessa Walker
30-05-2026
Ate there one night with my family. Come back the next night just for me. The food was amazing. Staff is family friendly. This is a must eat place.
Reviews Jay's Place