Discovering the Culinary Heritage of Lennys Silverton Meats Deli
Located at 1824 Hooper Ave, Toms River, NJ 08753, United States, Lennys Silverton Meats Deli stands as a cornerstone of the local community. For those who appreciate the art of traditional butchery and the comfort of a well-crafted deli sandwich, this establishment offers a unique experience that bridges the gap between a classic neighborhood market and a modern culinary destination. The atmosphere is defined by a commitment to quality and a deep-rooted respect for the craft of preparing fine meats, making it a frequent stop for residents and visitors alike who are seeking authentic flavors in the heart of New Jersey.
When you step inside, you are greeted by the distinct aroma of cured meats and fresh ingredients, a testament to the daily operations that prioritize freshness above all else. The deli has cultivated a reputation for consistency, ensuring that every patron receives the same level of care and attention to detail. Whether you are planning a large family gathering, looking for premium cuts for your own kitchen, or simply stopping by for a quick lunch, the team at Lennys Silverton Meats Deli focuses on providing a welcoming environment where the quality of the product speaks for itself.
What Sets This Deli Apart
Commitment to Quality Ingredients: The foundation of the deli is built upon a rigorous selection process for all meats and produce. By sourcing high-quality products, the establishment ensures that every sandwich and cut of meat meets a standard that keeps customers returning for years.
A Tradition of Craftsmanship: The staff possesses a deep understanding of butchery techniques, allowing them to provide expert advice on preparation methods and cooking tips. This knowledge-sharing approach empowers customers to make the most of their purchases at home.
Community-Centric Atmosphere: Beyond being a place of business, the deli serves as a local hub. The friendly service and personalized interactions foster a sense of belonging, making it a staple of the Silverton neighborhood culture.
Versatility in Offerings: The menu and product selection are designed to cater to a wide range of tastes and needs. From everyday essentials to specialty items, the deli balances traditional favorites with the practical requirements of a modern household.
The philosophy at Lennys Silverton Meats Deli is simple yet effective: treat the customer with respect and provide food that you would be proud to serve at your own table. This straightforward approach has allowed the deli to maintain its relevance in an ever-changing culinary landscape. By focusing on the fundamentals—freshness, expertise, and community connection—the establishment continues to thrive as a reliable source for those who value the intersection of quality food and genuine service.
Navigating the world of local delis can often be overwhelming, but this location simplifies the process by focusing on what truly matters. The layout is designed for efficiency, allowing patrons to browse the selection of meats and deli items with ease. Whether you are a long-time local or someone just passing through Toms River, the deli offers a glimpse into the local food culture that is both accessible and satisfying. It is a place where the pace of life slows down just enough for you to appreciate the quality of a well-prepared meal.
As you explore the various options available, you will find that the dedication to the craft is evident in every interaction. The team remains focused on maintaining the high standards that have defined their presence on Hooper Avenue. By prioritizing the needs of the community and upholding the traditions of a classic deli, Lennys Silverton Meats Deli ensures that it remains a vital part of the local culinary scene for years to come. It is more than just a place to buy food; it is a destination for those who appreciate the enduring value of a neighborhood butcher and deli.
A Lasting Impression
In conclusion, Lennys Silverton Meats Deli represents the best of what a local business can offer: a blend of professional expertise, high-quality products, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. By staying true to its roots while adapting to the needs of the modern consumer, the deli continues to be a preferred choice for those in Toms River and beyond. If you find yourself in the area, a visit to this establishment is an opportunity to experience a standard of service and quality that is increasingly rare in today's fast-paced world. We invite you to discover why so many consider this deli a cornerstone of their weekly routine.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Service options
Onsite services
Takeout
Delivery
Dine-in
Planning
Quick visit
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
On-site parking
Paid parking lot
Menus
Photos
Reviews Lennys Silverton Meats Deli
Damion Blake
05-04-2026
Quality meats, deli, bakery, and other goods.
From cuts of beef, pork and poultry to chocolate pretzels, cookies, cakes and fresh baked breads, Lenny's has what you need. Meats are a little higher priced … More
Justin Brett
05-04-2026
Solid sandwiches at great prices. Not sure you can find a better deal than Lenny's.
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Patrice Coscia
05-04-2026
Absolutely adore this place . My go to chocolate covered pretzels are always fresh and a huge variety . Love the atmosphere . More
Karen Cino
05-04-2026
Come on guys. Really? Just bought a crumb cake and you slapped a $7.99 sticker over the $5.99 one. Jacked up $2 in a week? I have a picture but can’t post here. Bad. Very bad. More
Steve Christ
05-04-2026
The absolute best hot roast beef you’ll ever have in your life! And I am from north Jersey we have Fiores but I’d put this up against them any day of the week! Every single thing you can order here is great and the people who make it are awesome More
Karen A
05-04-2026
Love Lennys in Silverton. It is the local Italian market, small grocery store, butcher shop. Prepared foods, salads, sandwiches at deli to choose from. Always a quick stop for me end of week. More
Justin Brett
05-04-2026
Solid sandwiches at great prices. Not sure you can find a better deal than Lenny's.
Meal type…
More
Joe Baudi
05-04-2026
My experince with Lenny is mostly with their fresh meats like steaks, sasuage and pork chops all of which are top notch. Like everywere, prices are concerning but the quality is there. Service at the counters is slow at times and I'd like … More
Andrew Geller
05-04-2026
Wow!! I have rode past here all the time. My aunt and sister have used the chicken breasts for meals. While my sister and I were there I decided to get some food for dinner. Chicken tenders and fries were delicious! The chicken parm sub was … More
the manning life mannings
05-04-2026
This is the only place to go for your meat.In other grocery items, they have everything. People, there are just always so nice.The meat so fresh, so amazing.So tender every time More
Billy Kanski
05-04-2026
I can’t say enough good things about this place! Whether you’re stopping in for a quick sandwich or looking for high-quality cuts of meat, this deli and butcher market absolutely delivers. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and always … More
SP: Walking Constellation
05-04-2026
This is a family owned supermarket for quality fresh baked homemade sandwiches, cold cuts, as well as baked goods, it's very clean and organized, everything is neatly placed and where it should be, however my only issue is the parking lot, … More
Lia Castellazzo
05-04-2026
Delicious and beautifully made with love! Go in there and try them out ❤️ you’ll be very pleased!!
Food:…
More
Ozzie Bandini
05-04-2026
Stumbled onto this deli while visiting family in Tom's River. This is the place to go to for sandwiches or hoagie, both are made to order and plenty of meat. The variety is huge, as are the portions. They have meats to grill, cook etc, and … More
Ed Cook
05-04-2026
Today's special at Lenny's Silverton Market on Hooper Avenue in Toms River was a Ham Club Sub with Bacon. We got the whole, with American cheese. It weighed in at just under 3 pounds, and cost just $10.95. It's a thing of beauty, and … More
Gabe Harper
05-04-2026
The atmosphere was radiant with a lot of the employees with customer relations, I saw friendly interpersonal conversations between many of the associates and customers making it feel like a very welcoming and family oriented place. The … More
stephen mayers
05-04-2026
Super friendly staff.
Bring your appetite. Best Subs I've ever had and the prices are amazing.
The Butcher department has everything you'd ever want. Specially Foods and salads are second to none.
Thanks Lenny's for always having the same quality and consistency all these years.
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Moderate noise
craig glaser
05-04-2026
omg are you kidding me, this place is the best of the best, old school butcher shop, fresh sandwiches & salads of all kinds, home made soups & deserts & much much more, go there to today you won't believe your eyes when you walk in this place. More
Tyler Dietlmeier
05-04-2026
If I could give zero stars I would, this place is an absolute joke. I went inside with my two year-old daughter at 3.40 pm To get a few things and to grab a breakfast sub “potato and egg” and even tho there was about 20 guys working behind … More
Kenneth Blair
05-04-2026
I cannot believe I haven't left a review for Lenny's yet! Between the breakfast sandwiches, the incredible subs, the prepared foods and the meat counter, this place is amazing! The staff is always friendly and helpful and even when the … More
Pete C
05-04-2026
The best local butcher, deli and food pantry in the area. Always fresh food with vibrant staff ready to serve. Get any of your ingredients needed or just grab a PEC to go. Great homemade baked dishes are available every day. They even … More
Donna Brooks
05-04-2026
Can't say enough great things about this place. Hoagies are excellent, portions are excellent, prices can't be beat for fresh made hoagies. You can buy fresh sliced lunch meat, they have fresh made bread and rolls, and a market for anything else you might need from milk to drinks to ice cream. More
Marco Viola
05-04-2026
Been reading all the great reviews and during my visit to NJ had to find out. The sandwiches are huge. Everything looks delicious and the counter guy really can craft a sandwich. Since my move to Florida, I've craved this type of food and atmospheres. No disappointments with Lenny's. More
Mary Ellen Levine
05-04-2026
Ordered sandwich and antipasto party platters for my daughter in law’s baby shower. A big hit! Sandwiches were fresh, packed with flavor and delicious. Antipasto was a perfect match and everyone loved it. Added the perfect lunchtime touch to the day. Thank you to the catering staff at Lenny’s. More
Lindsay Vitale (Griesbach)
05-04-2026
OUT OF THIS WORLD ! Everything is always unbelievably good here. Sandwiches are top notch and a great price. Their chicken salad is the best in NJ . Lovely staff and always happy to serve. Also their lace cookies are addicting 100/100. Huge portions and never left hungry More
Tim Rogers
05-04-2026
Just go to Lenny's!! Best subs on the East Coast. I mean the best. Overstuffed with fresh-sliced goodies, and the working back there are all super-friendly and focused on customer service.
Same thing at the meat counter and get the stuff chicken breasts. You can thank me later.
Fantastic Italian cookies, excellent imported pasta's and sauces, and the young ladies at the checkout are so friendly.
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Group size
Suitable for all group sizes
Alison Steward
05-04-2026
We've been going to Lenny's for four years. Great quality meats, great sandwiches and cheesesteaks at the deli. Went in today specifically to order two cheesesteaks amd because it's a Saturday there was a good line at the deli. While my husband waited I went to the butcher and picked up some meat for the next two nights. After waiting even longer than that took, my husband was informed that there were no cheesesteaks. The employee behind the counter was rude on top of that. Maybe put up a sign when you've run out of something and people may be waiting for nothing? Do better Lenny's.
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 5
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 2
Anonym Ouse
05-04-2026
Lemme tell ya, I got a soft spot for Lenny’s. The meat? Not bad—solid cuts, nothing to sneeze at. But sometimes, I feel like I gotta wrestle the guy behind the counter just to get the right portion.
Prices? Eh… fair, but my wallet feels it. Service? Some days it’s like a warm hug, other days I’m waitin’ so long I start thinkin’ about my life choices—again.
Still, I keep comin’ back. There’s just somethin’ about Lenny’s that feels… like family. A little rough around the edges, but you love ‘em anyway.
Verdict: 3 stars. I’m conflicted, but that’s love, right?”*
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 2
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 1
Reservation
Walk-ins only
Noise level
Quiet, easy to talk
Kayra Adi
05-04-2026
First time trying Lenny’s Silverton Market. The pastrami sandwich was actually pretty good flavorful and fresh. However, the cold ham sandwich was disappointing, not much taste. What really stood out though was the service: the guy making my sandwich was quite rude, which made the experience uncomfortable. Also got charged extra for grilled peppers, which wasn’t clearly mentioned upfront. Overall, mixed experience good pastrami, but service and consistency need improvement.
Food: 4
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 2
Jessica Fradella
05-04-2026
My husband was almost killed in a motorcycle accident over the summer. We are having a small Christmas due to him still healing. He wanted to smoke Prime Rib. I called Lennys on Friday 12/19 to ask the price for Prime Rib. I was told $19.99 per pound. I was told it was best to order the Prime Rib in advance for Christmas and pick it up a couple days before. The employee on the phone tried to lecture me on how big of a Prime Rib I should order, instead of listening to me when I said I needed 5 pounds. I ordered a 5 pound boneless Prime Rib to be picked up on Tuesday 12/23. On Tuesday, I drove half an hour to Lenny's to pick up my order. When I get home I open up the wrapping to make sure they didn't season it, since that was an option and due to food allergies I did not want seasoning. Upon opening the wrapper I see that I was charged $18.99 per pound and the Prime Rib is not boneless. I call the store and I am told they are transferring me to the butcher. After 15 minutes on hold without anyone answering, I hang up and call back. This time the butcher answers quickly. I am told that they take the bones out and put them back in for cooking so its really not a problem. I then point out that I paid for bones and I did not get the quantity of meat that I needed because the bone weight is included. I was then told to hang on and was promptly hung up on.
This was my first time using Lennys and I will never go back. I dont even care if the meat quality is good at this point, I will not support a business that treats people like that.
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$100+
Food: 3
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 3
Noise level
Moderate noise
Group size
Not sure
Parking space
Difficult to find parking
greg
05-04-2026
Growing up I didn't time in the Jersey shore area and if you have too them you know good food.. Bread, bagels, donuts, pastry, pizza, cutlets... And deli sandwiches. Long story short, this is THE CLASSIC ITALIAN DELI at the Jersey shore and absolutely the best cold cut hero I've ever had. Fresh hard or soft rolls, meat sliced in front of you for each sandwich.. Sliced thin and piled high. This was the tastiest, most tender Italian cold cut I've ever had, fresh mozzarella cheese and roasted peppers with plenty of oil and vinegar. Absolutely humongous, piled high, made to order and the price was absolutely fantastic..15 bucks for a whole hero!! The deli is huge, full of anything you expect in a traditional Italian deli. I don't live in Jersey but if I'm back I will definitely be going back to Lenny's and you should too
Order type
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Ham Cheese Salami, Salami and Cheese, Ham and Cheese
Recommendation for vegetarians
Somewhat recommend
Vegetarian offerings
Not sure
Vegetarian options
Great service, everyone was professional and friendly
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Parking
It will probably be crowded.. Don't be surprised
Reviews Lennys Silverton Meats Deli