Mr. Phil's Pizza, 7212 New Utrecht Ave, Brooklyn | Reviews

Welcome to Mr. Phil's Pizza in Brooklyn

Located in the heart of the community at 7212 New Utrecht Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228, Mr. Phil's Pizza stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of traditional pizza making. For those who appreciate the craft of a well-prepared pie, this neighborhood establishment offers a welcoming atmosphere where the focus remains squarely on quality ingredients and time-honored techniques. Whether you are a long-time resident of Brooklyn or just passing through the area, the kitchen at Mr. Phil's is dedicated to serving slices and pies that reflect a genuine passion for Italian-American culinary traditions.

Stepping into our shop, you are greeted by the inviting aroma of dough and savory toppings that define the authentic pizzeria experience. We believe that great pizza starts with the foundation, which is why we prioritize the consistency of our crust and the freshness of our sauce. Our commitment to the local neighborhood is reflected in every order we prepare, ensuring that each customer receives a meal that feels both familiar and satisfying. We invite you to experience a slice of Brooklyn culture where the simple joy of a good meal is always the main priority.

What Makes Our Pizza Special

Commitment to Quality Ingredients: We source our components with care, ensuring that every element—from the flour used in our dough to the blend of cheeses and fresh vegetables—meets a standard of quality that our patrons have come to expect.
Time-Honored Preparation Methods: Our approach to pizza making relies on patience and precision. By allowing our dough to develop properly and monitoring our ovens with an expert eye, we achieve a texture and flavor profile that honors the classic styles of New York pizza.
A Welcoming Neighborhood Atmosphere: Mr. Phil's Pizza is more than just a place to eat; it is a community hub. We strive to provide a friendly, accessible environment where neighbors can gather, share a meal, and enjoy a brief respite from the bustle of city life.
Consistency in Every Slice: We understand that our customers return because they know exactly what to expect. Our team works diligently to maintain high standards across every order, ensuring that the quality you enjoy today is the same quality you will find on your next visit.

The art of pizza making is a continuous journey of refinement and dedication. At Mr. Phil's Pizza, we take pride in our role within the Brooklyn food scene, contributing to the rich tapestry of local eateries that make this borough unique. We focus on the essentials—great dough, balanced toppings, and a hot oven—to create a product that speaks for itself. Our team is grateful for the support of our local community and remains focused on delivering a reliable, high-quality dining experience to everyone who walks through our doors.

Whether you are planning a casual lunch, a quick dinner after a long day, or simply craving a classic slice, we are here to serve you. We invite you to visit us at 7212 New Utrecht Ave to see for yourself why we remain a staple in the neighborhood. Thank you for choosing Mr. Phil's Pizza, where we believe that every great meal begins with a commitment to the craft and a respect for the people we serve. We look forward to welcoming you soon and sharing our love for authentic, well-made pizza with you and your family.

Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Service options
- Curbside pickup
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
- Small plates
- Wine
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
Amenities
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
Crowd
- Groups
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Pets
- Dogs allowed outside

Pasta Specialties
- Tortellini Alla Panna $13.50
- Penne Alla Frascana $13.95
- Tortellini Marinara $13.50
- Penne Alla Vodka $13.50
- Fettuccine Alfredo $13.50
Pizza
- Neapolitan Cheese Pizza (18") $18.00
- Neapolitan Cheese Pizza (14") $13.00
- Sicilian Neapolitan Cheese Pizza $21.00
- Neapolitan Cheese Pizza (16") $16.00
Appetizers Catering
- Mozzarella Sticks Catering $47.00
- Fried Calamari Catering $57.00
- Garlic Knots Catering $27.00
- Chicken Fingers Catering $47.00
- Fried Shrimp Catering $62.00
- Sautéed Broccoli Catering $42.00
Entrées Catering
- Eggplant Parmigiana Catering $47.00
- Chicken Marsala Catering $57.00
- Sausage Catering $42.00
- Chicken Francese Catering $57.00
- Shrimp Parmigiana Catering $62.00
- Tripe Catering $57.00
- Veal Parmigiana Catering $62.00
- Chicken Parmigiana Catering $52.00
- Eggplant Rollatini Catering $57.00
- Meatballs Catering $42.00
- Sausage & Peppers Catering $52.00
Beverages
- Snapple $3.25
- Soda (20 Oz) $3.25
- Soda (2 Liter) $4.50
- Water $2.25
- Soda (Can) $2.25
- Brisk Iced Tea $3.25
Salads
- Caesar Chicken Salad $12.95
- Tuna Salad $9.95
- Grilled Chicken Salad $12.95
- Antipasto Salad $10.50
- Tossed Salad $6.95
- Chicken Salad $12.95
- Chef's Salad $9.95
Specialty Calzones & Rolls
- Family Calzone $15.95
- Fried Calzone $7.95
- Ham Calzone $8.50
- Broccoli Roll $6.95
- Sausage Calzone $8.50
- Sausage Roll $6.95
- Vegetable Roll $6.95
- Calzone Combo $9.50
- Cheese Calzone $7.50
- Spinach Roll $6.95
- Chicken Roll $6.95
Appetizers
- Onion Rings $4.95
- Mozzarella Sticks $6.95
- Jalapeño Poppers $6.95
- Rice Ball $5.75
- Rice Ball Parmigiana $7.00
- Chicken Wings $12.50
- Chicken Tenders $6.95
- French Fries $5.50
- Garlic Knots $2.75
- Zucchini Sticks $6.95
- Beef Patties With Cheese $4.75
- Garlic Bread $5.50
- Beef Patties $4.00
Cold Heroes
- Ham & Cheese Hero $9.00
- Tuna Hero $8.50
- Salami & Cheese Hero $9.00
- Italian Combo Hero $9.00
- Roast Beef Hero $9.75
Baked Dishes
- Homemade Ravioli $11.95
- Baked Ziti Sicilian $12.95
- Stuffed Shells $11.95
- Manicotti $11.95
- Homemade Lasagna $12.95
- Baked Ziti $11.95
Pasta Dishes Catering
- Pasta With Broccoli Catering $47.00
- Pasta With Garlic & Oil Catering $42.00
- Pasta With Red Clam Sauce Catering $52.00
- Pasta With Vodka Sauce $52.00
- Pasta With Bolognese $52.00
- Pasta With Marinara Catering $47.00
- Pasta With Alfredo Sauce $52.00
- Pasta With White Clam Sauce Catering $52.00
Specials
- 2 Family Special $29.95
- 1 Family Special $29.95
Pasta Dishes
- Pasta With Marinara Sauce $11.95
- Pasta With Broccoli & Garlic $14.00
- Pasta With Tomato Sauce $11.00
- Pasta With Sausage $15.95
- Pasta With Meatballs $15.95
- Pasta With Mushroom Sauce $13.50
- Pasta With Meat Sauce $14.95
- Pasta With Garlic & Oil $12.50
- Pasta With Red Clam Sauce $13.95
- Pasta With White Clam $13.95
Baked Pasta Catering
- Baked Ziti With Eggplant Catering $42.00
- Baked Ziti Catering $37.00
- Meat Lasagna Catering $57.00
- Baked Ravioli Catering $52.00
- Baked Stuffed Shells Catering $52.00
Seafood Dishes
- Shrimp Scampi $18.95
- Shrimp Francese $18.95
- Shrimp Oreganata $18.95
- Fried Shrimp With French Fries $16.95
- Shrimp Parmigiana $18.50
- Fried Calamari $16.75
- Calamari Marinara $16.75
- Shrimp Marinara $18.95
Soups
- Soup Of The Day $5.95
Specialty Pizza
- Mr. Phil's Special Pizza $27.00
- Stromboli Stuffed Pizza $32.00
- Hawaiian Pizza $25.00
- Old Fashioned Grandma Pizza $22.00
- Upside Down Pizza $25.00
- Spinach Pizza $22.00
- Broccoli Pizza $22.00
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza $25.00
- BBQ Chicken Pizza $25.00
- Fresh Mozzarella Pizza $22.00
- White Pizza $22.00
- Sophia Loren Fresh Mozzarella Pizza $25.00
- Chicken Parmigiana Pizza $25.00
Salads Catering
- Caesar Salad Catering $37.00
- Tossed Salad Catering $32.00
- Cold Antipasto Salad Catering $47.00
- Caesar Salad With Chicken Catering $52.00
Italian Specialties
- Sausage & Peppers $16.50
- Chicken Francese $17.50
- Veal & Peppers $18.95
- Veal Marsala $18.95
- Chicken Parmigiana $16.50
- Veal Francese $18.95
- Chicken Marsala $17.75
- Eggplant Rollatini $16.95
- Eggplant Parmigiana $16.50
- Veal Parmigiana $18.50
Hot Heroes
- Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers Hero $10.95
- Eggplant Parmigiana Hero $9.75
- Potatoes & Eggs Hero $9.75
- Sausage Parmigiana Hero $9.75
- Meatball Parmigiana Hero $9.75
- Sausage & Peppers Hero $9.75
- Shrimp Parmigiana Hero $11.75
- Hot Roast Beef With Gravy Hero $10.75
- Sausage Hero $9.00
- Sausage & Eggs Hero $9.75
- Chicken, Lettuce & Tomatoes Hero $10.50
- Philly Steak & Cheese Hero $10.95
- Veal Parmigiana Hero $11.00
- Ham & Eggs Hero $9.75
- Meatball Hero $9.00
- Chicken Parmigiana Hero $10.50
- Peppers & Eggs Hero $9.75

Ryan W

30-05-2026

It isn't the best pizza in Brooklyn or in NYC but they are one of the best in the local area. They price things well too. Get the fries with cheddar cheese

Joanne Schulter

30-05-2026

The food here is ALWAYS excellent!! Great squares, heroes, pasta macaroni and calamari!! We love it here and call often. Give it a try...you won't go anywhere else! Eating my hot, just picked up food now. :)

Edaliz Carbonell

30-05-2026

One of the best pizzas in Brooklyn. Good sauce, cheesy and crunchy crust. Just the way I like it. Mozzarella sticks, zucchini sticks and cheesy fries ate good as well.

Jerry Flanagan

30-05-2026

They have a good lunch special. Any sub for $6.50. They are foot long subs, bread was great , lot's of meat on the Philly Steak and cheese. More

Angel Uruchima

30-05-2026

I've been coming here ever since I went to elementary school. Pizza still tastes amazing and the workers are super friendly. I love this place!