Pizza’s San Miguel, 760 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn | Reviews

Welcome to Pizza’s San Miguel in the Heart of Brooklyn

Located at 760 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11218, Pizza’s San Miguel stands as a dedicated neighborhood destination for those who appreciate the timeless craft of traditional pizza making. In a city defined by its diverse culinary landscape, our establishment focuses on the fundamental elements that make a meal memorable: quality ingredients, a consistent preparation process, and a welcoming atmosphere that invites guests to slow down and enjoy their food. We believe that a great pizza is more than just a quick bite; it is a reflection of the care put into every layer of dough, sauce, and cheese.

Our kitchen operates with a deep respect for classic techniques, ensuring that every pie served meets a standard of excellence that our local community has come to expect. Whether you are a long-time resident of the Brooklyn area or a visitor exploring the vibrant streets of Coney Island Avenue, we invite you to experience a slice of our commitment to authentic flavors. We prioritize the integrity of our recipes, focusing on the balance between a perfectly textured crust and the harmonious blend of toppings that define our signature offerings.

What Sets Our Kitchen Apart

Commitment to Quality Ingredients: We source our components with a focus on freshness and reliability, ensuring that every element—from the flour used in our dough to the savory notes in our sauce—contributes to a cohesive and satisfying flavor profile.
Dedicated Craftsmanship: Our preparation process is rooted in patience and precision. By allowing our dough to develop properly and monitoring our ovens with constant attention, we achieve a consistent bake that provides the ideal crunch and chewiness expected from a high-quality pizza.
Community-Focused Atmosphere: Situated conveniently on Coney Island Avenue, our location serves as a gathering point for neighbors and friends. We strive to maintain a space that feels comfortable and accessible, making it an ideal choice for casual dining or a reliable meal after a long day.
Consistency in Every Order: We understand that our patrons value reliability. Our team is trained to maintain high standards across every order, ensuring that whether you visit us frequently or for the first time, the experience remains true to our core values of quality and service.

A Culinary Staple on Coney Island Avenue

At Pizza’s San Miguel, we view our role in the Brooklyn community as more than just a food provider; we are a part of the daily rhythm of the neighborhood. By focusing on the essentials of pizza preparation and maintaining a steadfast commitment to our craft, we aim to provide a dining experience that is both honest and enjoyable. We invite you to visit us at 760 Coney Island Ave to see firsthand how our dedication to the art of pizza translates into every meal we serve. Our doors are open to those who appreciate the simple pleasure of a well-made pizza, prepared with care and served with pride in the heart of New York City.

We look forward to welcoming you soon and sharing our passion for quality food. Our team remains focused on refining our processes and listening to the feedback of our guests, as we believe that the best culinary experiences are those that grow alongside the community they serve. Thank you for considering Pizza’s San Miguel for your next meal, and we hope to become a regular part of your dining routine in Brooklyn.

Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Service options
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
Atmosphere
- Casual
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids

Side Orders
- Vegetables $7.00
- Spinach Saut $7.00
- Broccoli $7.00
Burgers
- San Miguel Burger $15.00
- Cheeseburger $12.95
- Pizza Burger $12.95
- Bacon Cheeseburger $13.50
- Hamburger $11.95
Specialty Pizza
- Veggie Pizza $14.00
- Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza $14.00
- Extra Large Grandma Pizza $32.00
- Chicken Fajita Pizza $14.00
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza $14.00
- Regular Cheese Pizza $11.00
- Pizza Mexicana $28.00
- Vodka Sauce Pizza $14.00
- Hawaiian Pizza $14.00
- Chicken And Broccoli Pizza $14.00
- Margherita Pizza $14.00
- BBQ Chicken Pizza $14.00
- Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza $14.00
Appetizers
- Caribbean Jerk Wings $9.50
- Original Barbecue Wings $9.50
- Sweet Chili Wings $9.50
- Mango Habanero Wings $9.50
- Chicken Tenders (6 Pieces) $9.00
- Side Of Dressing $0.75
- Beef Pattie $3.00
- Beef Patty With Cheese $4.00
- French Fries With Cheese $6.00
- Zeppoles (5 Pieces) $3.00
- Buffalo Wings $9.50
- Garlic Knots (5 Pieces) $3.00
- Very Hot Wings $9.50
- Jalapeño Poppers (6 Pieces) $7.00
- Mozzarella Sticks $9.00
- Coco Bread $3.00
- French Fries $4.50
San Miguel Tacos
- Steak Nachos $12.95
- Tinga / Chicken With Chipotle Sauce $3.00
- Chicken Taco / Pollo $3.00
- Campechanos Taco $3.00
- Burritos (You Have Meat Options To Pick ) $9.95
- Salted Beef Taco (Cecina) $3.00
- Roast Pork Taco / Pastor $3.00
- Steak Taco / Bistek $3.00
- Mexican Sausage Taco / Chorizo $3.50
- Spice Pork Taco / Enchilada $3.00
- Nachos (You Have Meat Options To Pick. Chicken, Pastor, Suadero, Or Tinga) $11.95
- Roast Meat Taco / Suadero $3.00
Create Your Own Pizza
- Create Your Own Pizza $11.00
Calzones
- Cheese Calzone $8.50
Salads
- Chicken Caesar Salad $11.00
- Classic Caesar Salad $7.00
- Garden Mix Salad $6.50
- San Miguel Chicken Salad $12.00
Pizza Slices
- Margherita Pizza Slice $5.00
- Caesar Salad Pizza Slice $5.00
- Veggie Pizza Slice $5.00
- Sicilian Pizza Slice $5.00
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice $5.00
- BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice $5.00
- Chicken And Broccoli Pizza Slice $5.00
- Hawaiian Pizza Slice $5.00
Rolls and Calzones
- Sausage And Pepper Calzone $6.50
- Chicken Roll $6.50
- Broccoli Calzone $6.50
- Chicken And Broccoli Calzone $7.50
- Spinach Calzone $6.50
Beverages
- Coca-Cola 2 Liters $4.00
- Pepsi (20 Oz) $2.25
- Ginger Bottle (20 Oz) $2.25
- Peach Snapple $2.25
- Ginger Can $1.25
- Diet Coke $1.25
- Sparkling Seltzer Water $1.25
- Coca-Cola (20 Oz) $2.25
- Kiwy - Strawberry Snapple $2.25
- Fanta Orange Can $1.25
- Orange Snapple $2.25
- Coca-Cola $1.25
- Sprite Can $1.25
- Pepsi Can $1.25
- Dr Pepper $1.25
- Root Beer (20 Oz) $2.25
- Bottled Spring Water $1.25
- Sprite Bottle (20 Oz) $2.25
- Mango Snapple $2.25
- Snapple Lemon Tea $2.25
- Sunkist Grape $1.25
Hot Heroes
- Sausage & Peppers Hero $8.50
- Chicken Parmesan Hero $9.00
- Meat Ball Parmesan Hero $8.50
- Buffalo Chicken Hero $8.00
Pasta Special
- Fettuccine Alfredo With Chicken $15.00
- Chicken Parmigiana Pasta Special $15.00
- Lasagna $11.00
- Penne Vodka With Chicken Pasta Special $15.00
- Meatballs Pasta Special $14.00
- Fettuccine Alfredo $12.00
- Penne Vodka Pasta Special $10.00
- Baked Ziti Pasta Special $10.00
Soups
- Chicken Noodle Soup $5.00

Sheik

30-05-2026

Always burning my pizza 👎 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

Dilya Radjabova

30-05-2026

They have bad service they take the money and forget orders we wasted hours of our time waiting for the pizza which did not come we had to cancel at last. They have bad service never buying again form here. They should have 0 stars not even 1

Perfect Wondering

30-05-2026

Disgusting,the pizza was so dry the bread literally tastes like rubber the deliver took over 2 hours and instead of a regular they gave me a cheese pizza with barely and sauce

Rizwana Shaikh

30-05-2026

No! A regular ‘ole slice of pizza should not taste like this - no flavor, salty, and rubbery cheese. Should’ve walked a couple of blocks more and gone to San Remos.

Sharkiya Yusupova

30-05-2026

Always delicious pizza. Order type Delivery… More