Located in the heart of the community at 59 Main St, Sidney, NY 13838, Sidney Joe's stands as a welcoming destination for those who appreciate a relaxed dining atmosphere. Our establishment is built on the simple philosophy of providing a comfortable space where neighbors, friends, and travelers can gather to enjoy a meal. We take pride in being a part of the local landscape in Sidney, offering a consistent experience that prioritizes quality and hospitality above all else. Whether you are stopping by for a quick bite during a busy workday or settling in for a longer evening with family, our doors are open to provide a genuine dining experience that reflects the spirit of our town.
At Sidney Joe's, we believe that the foundation of a great restaurant lies in the details of its service and the integrity of its preparation. We strive to create an environment where every guest feels recognized and valued from the moment they walk through our entrance on Main Street. Our team is dedicated to maintaining a clean, inviting, and efficient space that caters to the diverse needs of our patrons. By focusing on the fundamentals of good food and attentive service, we aim to remain a reliable choice for anyone looking for a pleasant meal in a setting that feels like home.
What Makes Us Unique
Community-Centric Atmosphere: We are deeply rooted in the Sidney area, fostering a friendly environment where local residents and visitors alike can connect and enjoy their time together.
Commitment to Quality: Our approach centers on selecting reliable ingredients and preparing dishes with care, ensuring that every plate meets a standard of consistency that our guests have come to expect.
Convenient Location: Situated centrally at 59 Main St, we provide an accessible gathering spot for those navigating through Sidney, making us an easy choice for lunch, dinner, or a casual meeting.
Dedicated Hospitality: Our staff is committed to providing attentive and respectful service, ensuring that your visit is comfortable and that your needs are met with professionalism and warmth.
The culinary landscape of New York is vast, but we believe there is always a place for a restaurant that values simplicity and sincerity. At Sidney Joe's, we do not try to overcomplicate the dining experience; instead, we focus on the elements that truly matter: the quality of the food, the comfort of the environment, and the kindness of our service. We understand that our guests have many options when they decide where to eat, and we are honored whenever they choose to spend their time with us. Our team works hard every day to earn that trust and to ensure that our presence on Main Street continues to be a positive contribution to the local community.
As we look toward the future, our goal remains the same as it was on our first day: to serve our guests with consistency and care. We invite you to visit us at 59 Main St to see for yourself what makes our approach to dining special. Whether you are a long-time local or just passing through the beautiful state of New York, you will find a seat waiting for you at Sidney Joe's. We look forward to welcoming you soon and providing you with a dining experience that is both satisfying and memorable, grounded in the values of hard work and genuine hospitality that define our business.
Thank you for considering Sidney Joe's for your next meal. We are proud to serve the Sidney community and are grateful for the ongoing support of our patrons. By maintaining our focus on high standards and a welcoming environment, we hope to remain a staple of the local dining scene for years to come. We encourage you to stop by, enjoy the atmosphere, and share a meal with us whenever you find yourself in the neighborhood. Your presence is what keeps our kitchen running and our doors open, and we are always happy to serve you.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Service options
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Highlights
Serves local specialty
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Quick bite
Small plates
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Restroom
Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Quiet
Crowd
College students
Groups
Tourists
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Usually plenty of parking
Menus
Calzone
Calzone$13.20
Large Subs
Large Bacon Sub$13.80
Large Ham Sub$11.40
Large Mixed Meat Sub$13.80
Large Pepperoni Sub$11.40
Large Cheese Sub$11.40
Large Turkey Sub$13.80
Large Chicken Tender Sub$15.00
Large Tuna Sub$11.40
Large Salami Sub$11.40
Hot Subs
Steak Sub$15.60
Meatball Parmesan Sub$14.10
Eggplant Parmesan Sub$14.10
Chicken Parmesan Sub$15.60
Slices
Slice$3.30
Large Pizzas
Large BBQ Rib Pizza$28.08
Large Chicken Wing Pizza$28.80
Large White Garlic Pizza$19.50
Large Cheese Pizza$19.50
Large Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza$30.00
Large Three Cheese Pizza$28.08
Large Honey BBQ Chicken Pizza$28.80
Appetizers
Chicken Tenders$12.00
6 Pepperoni Knots$10.80
French Fries$4.80
Mozzarella Sticks$7.50
12 Garlic Knots With Sauce$7.20
6 Garlic Knots With Sauce$4.20
3 Garlic Knots With Sauce$3.00
Combo #2$13.20
Combo #1$12.00
12 Pepperoni Knots$21.60
Onion Rings$7.20
Jalapeño Poppers$7.80
3 Pepperoni Knots$5.40
Garlic Bread With Cheese$7.20
Fried Ravioli$8.70
Wraps
Steak & Cheese Wrap$11.40
Tuna Wrap$9.30
Bacon Wrap$9.90
Turkey Wrap$9.90
Ham Wrap$9.30
Chicken Tender Wrap$11.10
Turkey And Bacon Wrap$11.10
Grilled Chicken Wrap$11.10
Wings
10 Wings$18.00
20 Wings$36.00
5 Wings$9.00
30 Wings$54.00
10 Boneless Wings$10.80
Dinners
Stuffed Shells$16.50
Lasagna$18.90
Cheese Ravioli$16.50
Spaghetti With Garlic & Oil$16.50
Manicotti$16.50
Baked Ziti With Mozzarella Cheese$20.40
Chicken Parmesan With Pasta$21.20
Eggplant Parmesan With Pasta$18.30
Spaghetti With Sauce$16.50
1/2 Order Of Spaghetti With Sauce$10.80
Fresh Salads
Ham Salad$10.20
Grilled Chicken Salad$0.00
Fresh Tuna Salad$0.00
Tossed Salad$0.00
Chicken Tender Salad$0.00
Antipasto$0.00
Turkey Salad$0.00
Side Salad (Dinner Size Salad)$4.80
Rolls
Roll$9.60
Drinks & Dessert
Pure Leaf Tea$3.30
20 Oz Bottled Soda$3.00
Cannoli$4.80
2-Liter$4.50
Small Pizzas
Small BBQ Rib Pizza$24.00
Small 14” Pizza$17.10
Small Honey BBQ Pizza$24.00
Small Chicken Bacon Ranch$25.20
Small Chicken Wing Pizza$24.00
Small Three Cheese Pizza$24.00
Small White Garlic Pizza$17.10
Reviews Sidney Joe's
Tyler Clark
30-05-2026
Always great pizza never disappointed
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Wings, Pepperoni Pizza, lg Peperoni-Sausage-Onion Pizza, Antipasto Salad, Stromboli Roll with Side of Sauce, Lunchtime Specialty Slices, Pepperoni Knots, Antipasto, Cheese Pizza Slice, Boneless Wings -Mild, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Noise level
Quiet, easy to talk
Wait time
No wait
cathy shanahan
30-05-2026
They have great calzones. They are big, enough for two people. They make the BEST garlic knots! They were very busy when I went to pick up my order but the staff were very Attentive and friendly to everyone. Friendly service with a smile! Highly recommend More
Josh
30-05-2026
Great establishment to get great pizza at! The managers &* staff are always extremely helpful &* the small town atmosphere where you get to know everyone &* they get to know you’re “usual” order is a charming bonus! (: More
Rob Wolfe
30-05-2026
Whenever I am in town, I always stop in for their 2 pizza slice special with a drink. Great flavor, huge size. Girl at the counter is always great and gets your order ready quickly. More
Junee Bug
30-05-2026
I don’t personally like any of their food here now. They used to be really great. I don’t know if it’s the staffing or they change the recipe but I’ve ordered pizza from there and it’s just been a soggy mess. Except their subs. That’s the … More
John Frawley
30-05-2026
Nice staff but no table service for a little while. Food is good with generous servings. I stop in every time I'm in town. *Update* As of 11/27/24 table service is back with friendly servers waiting to help you. Another fine meal. More
Joell McCarthy Nemeth
30-05-2026
Rodney was very patient and kind when he took my order. You guys are very lucky to have Rodney. You guys are lucky to have him because he was so kind and the pizza was amazing and the pepperoni bites delicious. When this jersey girl comes back to New York I’m totally ordering from you guys again. More
Tyler Clark
30-05-2026
Always great pizza never disappointed
Price per person
$1–10…
More
Sean Cone
30-05-2026
It was a good experience just that the service was in the greatest I took a while for me to get served you see yourself and so they don't know you're there so you got to wait for the waitress More
richard shanahan
30-05-2026
Probably one of the best places to get Pizza around here still not Philly pizza but the best I found up here More
Nature lover
30-05-2026
In the summer I'll grab me a slice or two with a fountain drink and set somewhere outside and enjoy my lunch. I'll also buy a pizza and antipasto salad they are awesome I do love to my surprise their peppercorn dressing. I recommend this place to all More
Marguerite Meheganmondore
30-05-2026
Always great food and dependable delivery
Order type
Delivery
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$50–100
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Wait time
1+ hour
Josh Kenyon
30-05-2026
If the pizza is fresh, made to order it's really good, but reheated not so much. Same thing goes for pizza leftovers, something happens with the cheese that I can't explain and it affects taste. Stromboli are fantastic, fresh and reheated, … More
Anthony C
30-05-2026
Pretty good slices and pies. I’m not much of a salad guy but this place has really good salads and serves good portions. Grilled chicken salsa is highly recommended. More
Claudia Mister
30-05-2026
Never had a problem with their food except for tonight ordered a ham and cheese calzone and we'll that's exactly what I got. An authentic real Italian calzone as ricotta cheese.
mary santana
30-05-2026
To go in and sit down and eat, excellent. Great food, great prices. Will never ever order delivery there. They take way too long and sometimes "forget" your order and then tell you they thought you were calling for a pick up. Called management over that one and received no sympathy at all. Go in all the time with my kids though.
Shanda Banks
30-05-2026
I wasn't able to leave a comment unless I picked a star. They don't even deserve that!! Called and ordered a large cheese pizza the other night at 630pm for delivery, food came at 745pm paid the guy and he left. Opened the pizza and it … More
Genevieve Healy
30-05-2026
Place is always clean. Staff in my experience has always been helpful, pleasant & food prepared quickly, usually within 10-30 minutes. More
branden debrock
30-05-2026
Can’t beat the service, today’s day in age nobody can make everyone happy but these guys really do a fantastic job at trying. They always accommodate and always treat people well. Keep up the great work love the food!
Curtis J. Kehr
30-05-2026
FOOD WAS EXCELLENT. The Young ladies ( the Boss's daughter and her helpers ) made us at home and made sure we had everything we needed constantly checking on us even though she had no waitress and just cleaned up a private party that had just finished. More
james hathaway
30-05-2026
Very good food. Very friendly service.
Order type
Take out…
More
Brandon Evans
30-05-2026
3rd week in a row the pizza has been messed up, 2 hrs late or not what we ordered. Half the pie we ordered ended up getting thrown away.
Terry Greco
30-05-2026
The best pizza I had in upstate New York in a loooong time! Seriously my family fought over the last slice! We live in south new berlin and have pizza places 7 miles away in every direction from New Berlin Norwich Morris and Oneonta and for me I’ll drive to Sidney now every time! Reheat value is 10x better than the rest too! More
Kimberly Wright
30-05-2026
To the 3 young man working up front at the counter today around 1:30 -1: 40 pm You 3 where doing a great job. Great communication,, working well with each other , calm. Great flow doing your guys thing. Wasn't sure why someone else had to come in and upset your guys flow. . THANK YOU GENTLEMAN FOR LUNCH, enjoy your guys work atmosphere as we waited . Keep up the great work.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 2
Taylor Reed
30-05-2026
I’m really disappointed. We spent $40 on a large and a small pizza, which we expected, asking for the pizza to be cooked well done. It was not even close to well done, the dough was rawer than raw. The pizza was extremely flimsy, and I had to cook the pizza so I wasn’t eating raw dough. If we’re going to spend $40, please cook the pizza all the way. I shouldn’t have to put it in the oven to finish cooking it.
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 2
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 4
Reservation
Reservations not required
Jessica Jewell
30-05-2026
The pizza was decent but the service was above and beyond for the fact that they did not have any servers on staff.
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 4
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Seating type
Indoor dining area, Booth seating
L. Fredella
30-05-2026
Usually I go here if I want a quick, nicely priced. Been going here for years. However, please hire people who can take an order on a phone. I repeated "One small pepperoni and garlic pizza and a side of mozzarella sticks" four times before I had to hang up. He repeated the order wrong back four times. He sounded stoned. Don't blame this on the phone- it was perfectly clear with no noise in the background. Is he messing up with orders so he doesn't have to work? If you can't take an order properly it's virtually guaranteed that my order will be wrong when I pick it up.
Food: 3
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 3
Marsha Kellesvig
30-05-2026
Huge Calzone! Delicious, and exactly what I wanted. I have leftovers - more than enough for 2 meals.
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Justin Case
30-05-2026
Buffalo ain't got nothing on these wings. Meaty, cooked to perfection and smothered in their signature wing sauce. If you like wings, it's definitely worth the trip.
Order type
Take out
Meal type
Other
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 4
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 4
Recommended dishes
Wings
Cindy Wood
30-05-2026
The food is acceptable usually pretty good.
I just want to say that our deliveries have been tough.
But last night (Monday) we had a wonderful delivery driver she was very honest. I wish I knew her name so I could mention it. But again we appreciate it!
We hope she sees this..
Order type
Delivery
Meal type
Other
Food: 4
Service: 3
Madison Banks
30-05-2026
As a lifetime resident of Sidney, Joe's Pizzeria (formerly Joe and Vinny's) is THE place to go for pizza. There have always been many options in Sidney for pizza, but no one does New York style pizza like Joe's. They also have delicious subs, salads, and hot dinners, and their wings are meaty, crispy, and the house-made sauce is so good.
The staff is friendly and helpful. If there is ever any issue with an order, it is promptly fixed. They go above and beyond for their customers. Five stars all around. This family owned restaurant has made a lifer out of me!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Ariel
30-05-2026
The first pizza was terribly made the cheese and pepperoni are everywhere. The second pizza was beautiful. So,I’ll meet you in the middle with this review. More
Christopher Yandell
30-05-2026
Family owned pizza place with cheap delicious pizza. They have a large seating area in the back too so it’s not just takeout. Best pizza in the area in my opinion. More
Bree Gelina
30-05-2026
You're craving a real Italian pizza then come to Joe's because they do not disappoint. I had a very simple white sauce cheese pizza and topped with garlic absolutely to die for. Not to mention the people that work here are super nice. Can eat in there's a dining room in the back sometimes there's a waitress sometimes there's not no big deal The pie is worth it all.
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Wait time
No wait
jim greco
30-05-2026
From Long Island. Very picky about pizza.
The service was great, and the food was even better! Grilled chicken over salad. Chicken seasoned and cooked to perfection. Pizza and garlic knots were … More
Louis Wilber
30-05-2026
Boneless wings are sold as 10 piece but they only give you nine. I could understand once being a mistake but both orders were short and one was made with extremely small pieces.
John Amirault
30-05-2026
Fran and the staff all go above and beyond with giving help. Whatever I ordered is made promptly. I have a bad back, Foley crutches make carrying things almost impossible, Fran makes sure the staff help with carrying soda to the table, She has also allowed me to get delivery when extremely backed up on delivery orders.
Ron Moretz
30-05-2026
Went to Walton location got a pepperoni pizza I’ll tell you. It was delicious. Best pizza I’ve had and many many years. I live in Bainbridge now and I was told there’s a Joe’s in Sydney so I’m going up there right now and get myself a pizza. I can’t wait. More
Kumano Kashiwagi
30-05-2026
I'm not getting pizza from here again!! Not after I watched a girl with a stretched out dough in her hands that hung to her knees, walk from the pizza station weaving through the staff going into the kitchen, only to emerge from the kitchen … More
R. Ashby
30-05-2026
Does anyone know if Jeff Brooker is still living in this neighborhood?
Food: 5…
More
Richard Winters
30-05-2026
Joe and Vinny's in Sidney is a great spot for NY Pizzeria style hot Philly cheesesteak subs. They know what a real Philly cheesesteak is like (it's fast food; hot dog buns with steaks and cheese whiz - by the dozen). If you've been to … More
Marguerite Meheganmondore
30-05-2026
Always great food and dependable delivery
Order type
Delivery…
More
R. Ashby
30-05-2026
Does anyone know if Jeff Brooker is still living in this neighborhood?
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Reviews Sidney Joe's