Located at 926 Fay Blvd, Cocoa, FL 32927, United States, Troys Pizzeria stands as a welcoming destination for those who appreciate the timeless craft of traditional pizza making. Our establishment is built upon a simple philosophy: quality ingredients, a warm atmosphere, and a genuine commitment to serving our local community. Whether you are a long-time resident of Cocoa or just passing through the area, we invite you to experience a slice of authentic culinary dedication that prioritizes flavor and consistency in every single order.
At Troys Pizzeria, we believe that a great meal begins with the basics. We focus on the foundational elements of pizza—the dough, the sauce, and the cheese—to ensure that every bite meets the expectations of our patrons. Our kitchen team works diligently to maintain high standards of preparation, ensuring that each pie is crafted with care. We understand that in a world of fast-paced dining, there is still a significant place for a neighborhood spot where you can count on a reliable, satisfying meal prepared by people who care about the final product.
What Makes Our Pizzeria Special
Commitment to Quality Ingredients: We prioritize sourcing reliable components for our pizzas, ensuring that every topping and base element contributes to a balanced and enjoyable flavor profile.
A Welcoming Neighborhood Atmosphere: Our location on Fay Blvd is designed to be a comfortable space where individuals, families, and friends can gather to enjoy a meal without unnecessary pretense.
Consistent Culinary Standards: We strive to maintain a high level of consistency in our kitchen, ensuring that your experience remains positive every time you choose to dine with us.
Dedicated Local Service: Being part of the Cocoa, Florida community is central to our identity, and we take pride in serving our neighbors with friendliness and efficiency.
The process of creating a memorable pizza involves more than just assembling ingredients; it requires an understanding of heat, timing, and the chemistry of dough fermentation. At Troys Pizzeria, we respect these traditional methods while remaining focused on the needs of our modern customers. We recognize that our guests have many choices when it comes to dining out, and we are grateful for the opportunity to be a part of your mealtime decisions. Our team is constantly looking for ways to refine our processes, ensuring that we remain a staple for those seeking a classic pizza experience in the heart of Florida.
Beyond the pizza itself, we value the relationships we build with our customers. We believe that a restaurant is only as good as the community that supports it, and we are proud to be situated in such a vibrant part of Cocoa. Our goal is to provide a reliable dining option that fits seamlessly into your busy schedule, whether you are looking for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner at the end of a long day. We invite you to stop by, see our space, and enjoy the results of our hard work.
As we continue to serve the residents of 926 Fay Blvd and the surrounding areas, our focus remains steadfast on the principles that started it all. We are not interested in trends or gimmicks; instead, we focus on the enduring appeal of a well-made pizza served in a friendly environment. We appreciate the trust our customers place in us when they choose to spend their time and resources at our establishment. It is this trust that drives us to keep our ovens hot and our standards high, day after day.
Visit Us Today
If you find yourself in Cocoa and are craving a straightforward, satisfying meal, we encourage you to visit Troys Pizzeria. We are conveniently located on Fay Blvd and are ready to welcome you with open doors and a hot oven. We look forward to serving you and becoming a regular part of your dining routine. Thank you for supporting local businesses and for choosing to share your meals with us.
Amenities and More
Menus
Salads
Garden Salad$12.75
Chicken Caesar Salad$13.75
Greek Salad$12.75
Side Salad$7.00
Antipasto Salad$12.75
Beverages
2-Liter$5.00
Pasta
Chicken Alfredo$15.50
Bang Bang Pasta$16.50
Seafood Lasagna$16.50
Eggplant Parmigiana$15.50
Shrimp Alfredo$16.50
Spaghetti And Meatballs$15.50
Stuffed Shells$15.50
Baked Ziti$15.50
Desserts
Cannoli$4.50
Chocolate Cake$8.00
Cheesecake$7.00
Cinnamon Knots$8.00
Hot Italians
Spinach Roll$11.75
Calzone$12.25
Sausage Roll$11.75
Chicken Roll$12.75
Stromboli$11.75
Veggie Roll$12.75
Sides
Side Of Ranch$0.75
Side Of Fries$5.00
Side Of Marinara$1.00
Side Sausage Links$4.25
Side Of Alfredo$1.50
Side Of Blue Cheese$0.75
Side Garlic Butter$1.00
Side Meatball$4.00
Subs
Sausage, Pepper & Onions Sub$12.75
Grilled Chicken Parm Sub$12.75
Eggplant Parm Sub$12.75
Meatball Parm Sub$12.75
Italian Combo Sub$12.75
Philly Cheesesteak Sub$13.75
Starters
Cheese Sticks$8.50
Chicken Fingers And Fries$12.50
Buffalo Wings$15.50
Bang Bang Shrimp$11.75
Bang Bang Tacos$13.75
Garlic Knots$8.00
Shrimp Scampi$11.75
Stuffed Mushrooms$9.00
French Fries$5.00
Cheesy Knots With Bacon$9.50
Cheesy Knots$9.00
Corn Nuggets$8.00
Firecracker Shrimp$11.75
Boneless Wings$14.50
Pizza
White Pizza (24")$29.50
Cheese Pizza (24")$26.50
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza (18")$27.00
Hawaiian Pizza (16")$23.00
Margherita Pizza (18")$26.00
Hawaiian Pizza (24")$32.50
Troy's Special Pizza (18")$30.00
Margherita Pizza (24")$32.50
Cheese Pizza (16")$17.50
Vegetarian Pizza (18")$27.00
Greek Pizza (18")$29.00
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza (16")$24.00
White Pizza (16")$20.50
Troy's Special Pizza (Sicilian 16")$30.00
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza (24")$33.50
White Pizza (18")$23.00
Greek Pizza (24")$34.00
Tomato Basil Pizza (16")$24.00
Chicken Spinach Pizza (16")$25.50
Cheese Sicilian$21.50
Meat Lovers Pizza (16")$23.00
Vegetarian Pizza (16")$24.00
Meat Lovers Pizza (24")$33.50
Cheese Pizza (18")$20.00
Margherita Pizza (16")$23.00
Tomato Basil Pizza (24")$33.50
Troy's Special Pizza (24")$35.00
Cheese Pizza (Sicilian 16")$21.50
Hawaiian Pizza (18")$26.00
Chicken Spinach Pizza (18")$29.50
Meat Lovers Pizza (Sicilian 16")$27.00
Vegetarian Pizza (24")$34.50
Troy's Special Pizza (16")$26.00
Meat Lovers Pizza (18")$27.00
Chicken Spinach Pizza (24")$34.00
Tomato Basil Pizza (18")$27.00
Greek Pizza (16")$25.50
Photos
Reviews Troys Pizzeria
Tim
05-04-2026
We had wanted to try a different pizza place. Troy's was close so we ended up ordering from there. We ordered a large pizza with extra cheese, bacon, onions and ham. When i walked in, no one greeted me immediately, so i sat down (I was the … More
DKJohnson92 Johnson
05-04-2026
Used to order from here all the time. I decided to order there Chicken Alfredo and it was super dry. Was not enough Alfredo sauce and the noodles were not cooked enough. Disappointed because they usually have the best chicken Alfredo around More
Don Case
05-04-2026
Pizza and garlic rolls were great but the shrimp tasted weird and the lettuce was soggy! The shrimp sauce was not satisfied by our family. We do a lot of shrimp orders from other restaurants. Beef of Brady’s has better shrimp More
Joey Lampone
05-04-2026
Just had the hot and spicy wings. Excellent!! Wings were a good size and hot and spicy they were. Had their pizza not to long ago and it was good as well. Could stand a little bit more of olive oil and sauce so that it's dripping when you pick it up. More
Carol W
05-04-2026
Best meatballs and meat pizza ever. The girl who answered the phone was so polite and funny and helped me out only place we will go for pizza now on More
Shannon Martin
05-04-2026
11/25/24 - ordered calzone with pepperoni and mushrooms and a cannoli for pickup. Calzone was very disappointing, undercooked and way too much ricotta ( I love ricotta so for me to say it was too much trust me it was an obscene amount). No … More
Katie
05-04-2026
I asked for chicken and cheese fries . The chicken was gross and tasted like fish . And the fries were soggy and I got regular fries not cheese fries very disappointing . Never wasting my money here More
MadNitr0
05-04-2026
The pizza by the slide is quick and ready in time for lunch. Their fresh pizzas are great. The setting area is a little small but I've never had a problem finding a seat. There's always room for improvement but if your looking for pizza I would definitely recommend Troy's More
Kiera Marshall
05-04-2026
Cute little spot. The service was friendly and the food came out at a reasonable time.
Pizza was pretty good, the slices are huge! … More
Jason Watkins
05-04-2026
Restaurant Review: Troy's Pizzeria in Port St. John
I recently had the pleasure of dining at Troy's Pizzeria in Port St. John, and … More
marielys soto
05-04-2026
Went there today with my pastor and friend. The pizza was great. However, while we were having a conversation, the cashier began cleaning a Table and moving chairs abruptly. The noise was so loud we couldn’t even hear ourselves speak. I … More
Dustin Flatt
05-04-2026
Highly suggest the 24 inch meatlovers pizza its great but you better be hungry lol
Order type
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$30–40
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Wait time
10-30 min
Ann Marie Cornacchia
05-04-2026
Holy cow the pizza slice on the largest size pizza we ordered was bigger than my head! Delicious tasting and exceptional crust. Perfection. Online order went without a glitch and was delivered on time and a very polite delivery person delivered it. So yummy. Highly recommend!!! More
Rhett Seberry
05-04-2026
This was my brothers favorite pizza place, and I try to find myself over here to have a white pizza slice once a year on his birthday.. Overall though really I never ordered here much outside of that... however we are stuck home due to … More
Scott davis
05-04-2026
Best meatballs I ever had and I grew up in a town nicknamed Little Italy. 🇮🇹 All the food is excellent, but you have to try the meatballs. … More
Dustin Flatt
05-04-2026
Highly suggest the 24 inch meatlovers pizza its great but you better be hungry lol
Order type…
More
Anthony Visone
05-04-2026
Troy’s has outstanding NY style pizza, Stromboli & stuffed mushrooms. Stromboli & stuffed mushrooms are our favorite go to items. However, if you order Stromboli or stuffed mushrooms make sure you ask if JOHN is working. He is a master of the Stromboli & mushrooms. Last time I ordered a Stromboli when John wasn’t working it was covered in corn meal that made it taste like sawdust and it was a major disappointment. Plus the fillings were meager. John is the man!! I don’t order from here unless he’s working. Their pizza is fairly consistent and about the closest to real New York pizza where I was born & raised so I’m pretty picky about my pizza!! This is a takeout place. There’s a few tables but it’s usually hit as the pizza oven in the restaurant. I don’t recommend dining in.
Order type
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 3
Spencer Hedlund
05-04-2026
Very great place to eat, great customer service, great environment like an old mom and papa restaurant. Excellent pizza, some of the best around, we came in by ourself place was empty about 2 hours before dark and were the only ones getting pizza. Great business with great pizza. Good Job everyone More
Seth Craigen
05-04-2026
This place is a legit pizza shop like you'd see in New York. The people at the desk are very nice and the pizza is truly top notch. There have been issues with phone calls being completed, but it normally goes through on the 2nd or 3rd attempt. The prices are great for what you get. Definitely a must try for great pizza. More
Murfam Post LLC
05-04-2026
Service was very good as the only guest inside. The Black Olives I ordered were not on the pie. The crust was very hard, actually worried about chipping or breaking a tooth. Lacked flavor too. The Pepperoni’s were a good topping. The cheese lacked a flavor or fresh mozzarella authenticity for a pizza. Price to size was very fair.
Brittany Locke
05-04-2026
The food was great and the service was absolutely amazing. my waitress Victoria was on point taking our order and drinks . She made sure everything was perfect and came to check on us through out our meal. Can't wait to go back ! More
Diadema Mislán
05-04-2026
Been in PSJ long enough, this used to be my go to place. Zero customer service now lol wow. The worst pizza place I've ever been to honestly. Lady with glasses/ blonde hair and purple shirt was way too concerned about her poker game than … More
David Hager
05-04-2026
This reminded me so much of a New York Pizza place. Family-owned and everybody pitching in the way used to be. Very friendly staff excellent pizza reasonable prices! Decorated. Which photos of NASA stuff this is definitely a place I would … More
Cole Jenkins
05-04-2026
Drive past all the time, decided I would give Troy’s pizza a shot. Ordered a tomato basil Sicilian style pie. As an Italian, when it comes to food, especially Italian food I am what I like to consider an expert. Let me tell ya this pie was … More
Big Boy Dining Out
05-04-2026
Troy's Pizzeria- Port St. John, FL- 4 Stars
“Oh, joy,” I thought as I stared at the window on my random name generator, another Pizza joint. But hey, at least it wasn't a franchise! The name in question was that of Troy's Pizzeria in beautiful Port St. John...oh, who am I kidding, it's OTB and I don't like going OTB, alas duty calls.
I truly enjoyed Troy’s Pizzeria and recommend it over and other pizza joint in PSJ.
As I was debating which bridge to use to cross the river, I looked up and I was there (it's not that bad of a drive after all). The tidbit of information that got my curiosity up was the fact that Troy's touted itself as serving “New York Style” pizza. For those not in the know, NY Style pizza is made with a defining overly large hand-tossed crust that is thin except the edge, this allows for the preferred method of ingestion, the New York fold.
Upon entering Troy's Pizzeria I was immediately taken in by how clean the place was. I can get used to this aspect of a post-COVID world as who doesn't like a clean eating establishment? While it was nothing out of the ordinary décor wise, I found it to be a quaint little parlor aptly manned by Amanda. I asked Amanda for one slice of white pizza and one order of their stuffed shells with the proverbial garlic knots and a small side salad.
The salad Amanda soon returned with was chock full of fresh vegetables and crisp, green lettuce. Sadly, the dressing was obviously out of a bucket. The garlic knots were just that, garlic knots. They were cooked properly and tasted fine, but certainly nothing extraordinary here.
Moving on to the slice of white pizza. What I really like here is the crust. I hate overdone crust and this was obviously made to order, cooked properly and was delightfully amusing on the palate. The toppings were fresh, the sauce was tasty and it folded perfectly! Great job, Troy's!! The stuffed shells, while not bad in any way, didn't make the same impression on me as the slice of pie I just scarfed down did. The shells were cooked properly, the sauce was adequate and the rest is, as they say, history.
I must make a disclosure here to my loyal readers. When I am comparing Italian food I rate pizza joints against pizza joints and sit-downs vs. sit-downs. So, for future reference, please don't ask me how a pizza place stacks up against a family-oriented sit-down Italian joint that has the obligatory pizza on the menu.
The Big Boy says, “If you're a transplant, visitor, or local in the mood for some up the coast pizza, Troy's Pizzeria is serving fresh slices of hot New York Style Pizza Pie!” #iamthebigboy #bigboydining
Peggy Haskell
05-04-2026
We came in this evening (7:30) to celebrate my daughter’s graduation. We ordered $100 worth of food and tipped the ladies a hefty $25. I understand that they close at 8pm however, they had no right treating my family and I the way they did. The younger looking girl slammed the plates on the table as she brought the food out. We were kind enough to stack our plates on the pizza tray as we finished our food in an attempt to make it easier to clean up. Once I finished putting our food in the to go containers they actually turned OFF all the lights in the dinning room. Only I was standing at the time. Very rude!!!!!
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 1
Reservation
Reservations not required
Recommendation for vegetarians
Would not recommend
Spencer Griffin
05-04-2026
A wonderful pizza place with delicious food and friendly staff. We shared a stromboli and they even had a coiple of arcade games! We'll be back for sure.
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$40–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Quiet, easy to talk
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Alex Broadbent
05-04-2026
Wow! Great pizza. True Italian pizza, Oh and the large is a Huge LARGE. It is big. (the pics are a small pizza FYI) We have been looking for a great place in Port St. John's and we have found it. Never had a bad pizza or delivery. Once they gave us a free pizza.
Conor Vogt
05-04-2026
Really impressed with the quality of the pizza. Closest thing I've had in flavor and texture to authentic New York pizza in Florida. Highly recommend!
Order type
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Jon C
05-04-2026
Best pizza around in my opinion. Used to go all the time but unfortunately moved far away. If they delivered 1,500 miles, I'd still be ordering frequently. If you live near by or are passing through, I highly recommend. Still on their email list and when I see them coming through, I instantly miss this establishment.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Mat Barnes
05-04-2026
i went in the middle of the day on a sunday so my expectations werent altogether high. there was a group of what i could only describe as regulars playing poker and chatting it up, which was quite pleasant. The cashier was a young lad, friendly but to the point. I walked in and ordered their spaghetti and meatballs to dine in and a calzone with pepperoni and mushrooms to go. spaghetti took close to 20 minutes to come out came with garlic knots that were decent, one of which wasnt baked all the way through. i have my suspicions that the spaghetti was a "unthaw and bake" affair due to it being in a metal pie pan when it was served. I was a bit peckish so I dug in without a second thought. upon refection it could have used more sauce and the meatballs, while impressive, were dried out on the top. very filling but underwhelming as far as taste.
As I got up to leave I retrieved my calzone, which i got togo so as to have for lunch the next day. it sat in the fridge overnight and today i took it out to rebake it (325 for 15min) and cut it open. see pictures. the calzones from this place came highly recommended by other locals so i was excited to try them out. I have not had many calzones in my life but they have time and again disappointed me. I thought they should come as a wrapped up pizza; ingredients evenly distributed surrounded by crust. the crust was good, but the ingredients were stacked together and each bite was one thing at a time. not especially appetizing honestly and I do not believe i'll be ordering these two items again. will see about editing on a following visit where i will order their signature pizza and take that for a spin, but honestly i'm not looking forward to it.
the spaghetti, side salad, and calzone (no drink) cost $37. i'll keep supporting local businesses, but it is tough sometimes.
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 3
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 3
Group size
1 person, 2 people, 3-4 people
Recommendation for vegetarians
Would not recommend
Dietary restrictions
its a local pizzeria, you either know what to expect or you come in to find out.
Parking space
Difficult to find parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Parking
not a lot of parking, but i dont think many people drive here to dine in so it does not seem to be an issue.
Kid-friendliness
there is a little arcade machine here but otherwise i wouldnt necessarily suggest bringing kids to dine in.
Reviews Troys Pizzeria