Located in the heart of Elmira, New York, at 200 E Church St, Ill Eagle Taphouse stands as a welcoming destination for those who appreciate a relaxed atmosphere and a focus on quality beverages. Our establishment is designed to serve as a community hub where locals and visitors alike can gather to unwind, share stories, and enjoy a curated selection of drinks in a setting that feels both comfortable and authentic. We believe that the best experiences are built on simplicity, genuine hospitality, and a deep respect for the craft of brewing and social gathering.
Stepping into our space, you will find an environment that prioritizes comfort and conversation. Whether you are stopping by after a long day at work, meeting friends for a weekend catch-up, or simply exploring the vibrant culture of Elmira, our team is dedicated to providing a seamless and enjoyable experience. We take pride in being part of the historic fabric of Church Street, contributing to the local energy that makes this area a unique place to spend time.
What Makes Us Unique
At Ill Eagle Taphouse, we focus on the elements that matter most to our patrons. Our approach is centered on creating a space that feels like a home away from home, where the quality of the environment is just as important as the quality of the service. Here are a few reasons why guests choose to spend their time with us:
A Curated Selection of Beverages: We take great care in selecting a diverse range of options, focusing on variety and quality to ensure that every guest finds something that suits their palate. Our rotating selection reflects a passion for discovery and a commitment to offering something fresh and interesting.
A Welcoming Community Atmosphere: Our taphouse is designed to foster connection. With an open layout and a friendly team, we strive to create an inclusive environment where everyone feels comfortable, whether you are a regular or a first-time visitor.
A Prime Location in Elmira: Situated at 200 E Church St, we are conveniently located for those exploring the downtown area. Our position in the city makes us an ideal starting point or a final stop for your evening plans in Elmira.
Commitment to Quality Service: We believe that great service is the foundation of a memorable visit. Our staff is dedicated to ensuring that every guest feels valued and well-attended to from the moment they walk through our doors until they depart.
We understand that the modern diner and social seeker values transparency and a relaxed pace. That is why we avoid unnecessary complexity, focusing instead on the fundamentals of a great taphouse experience. Our space is intentionally designed to be a retreat from the noise of daily life, allowing you to focus on the people you are with and the drink in your hand.
The history and character of Elmira are important to us, and we strive to reflect that spirit in everything we do. By maintaining a space that is clean, inviting, and consistently managed, we hope to remain a staple for those who value quality time and good company. We invite you to visit us at 200 E Church St to see for yourself what makes our taphouse a special part of the local landscape.
Join Us for a Refreshing Experience
Whether you are a long-time resident of New York or just passing through the beautiful Finger Lakes region, Ill Eagle Taphouse is here to offer a warm welcome. We are constantly looking for ways to improve our guest experience and ensure that our taphouse remains a place where memories are made. We look forward to serving you soon and becoming a part of your routine in Elmira. Come by, pull up a seat, and enjoy the unique atmosphere that we have worked hard to cultivate for our community.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating
Service options
Outdoor seating
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Highlights
Bar games
Fast service
Fireplace
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Live music
Live performances
Rooftop seating
Serves local specialty
Trivia night
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Comfort food
Food
Food at bar
Happy hour drinks
Hard liquor
Late-night food
Private dining room
Quick bite
Small plates
Wine
Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Free Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Historic
Trendy
Crowd
College students
Groups
Tourists
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Usually plenty of parking
Menus
Handhelds
Steak Quesadilla$18.24
Chicken Quesadilla$15.96
Cheese Steak$20.52
ILL EAGLE Smash Burger$19.38
Regular Cheese Burger$17.10
Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich$18.24
Build Your Burger$0.00
Spicy Chicken Sandwich$15.96
Shareables/ Specials
Italian Sausage Bites$18.24
Pork Bites$17.10
Mozzarella Sticks$11.40
Ahi Tuna$18.24
BONELESS! Wings$0.00
Red Eye Burger$19.38
Chicken Parm Sandwich$18.24
Pretzel$17.10
Ruben Tots$13.68
Crab Cakes$18.24
Traditional Wings$0.00
Lunch Specials
Basil Pesto Sandwich$13.68
Turkey Sandwich$17.10
Italian Sandwich$17.10
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich$17.10
Pesto Sandwich$13.68
Club Sandwich$13.68
Buffalo Chicken Flatbread$15.96
Soda
Ginger Ale$2.85
Diet Pepsi$2.85
Pepsi$2.85
Sprite$2.85
Root Beer$2.85
Alcoholic Beverages
Raspberry White Claw 6pk 12oz Cans$22.80
Decoy Cabernet Sauvignon$27.36
Black Cherry White Claw 6pk 12oz Cans$22.80
Nutrl 4pk 12oz Cans$18.24
Coppola Prosecco$22.80
Ithaca Lakeside Lager 4pk 16oz Cans$18.24
Hazlitt Bramble Berry$20.52
Awestruck Lovestruck Cider 4pk 16oz Cans$18.24
Wagner Dry Riesling$22.80
Good Boy Tea-Vodka Seltzer Variety 8pk$31.92
Hamburg Louie IPA 6pk 12oz Cans$18.24
Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza$14.00
Cheese Pizza$14.00
Reuben Pizza$14.00
Breakfast Pizza$18.00
Mediterranean Pizza$14.00
Chicken Wing Pizza$14.00
Chicken Bacon Ranch$14.00
White Garlic Pizza$14.00
Basil Pesto Pizza$14.00
Dill Pickle Pizza$14.00
Sides
Fries$4.56
Potato Chips$3.42
Salads
Taco Salad$0.00
Caesar Salad$13.68
Strawberry Field Salad$15.96
House Salad$13.68
Cobb Salad$18.24
Friday Fish Fry
Fish Fry$25.08
Broiled Fish$25.08
Photos
Reviews Ill Eagle Taphouse
George Johnson
05-04-2026
The bartender Kelly was the biggest help ever. So sweet and kind and may be the best bartender in town. My first time coming to Ill Eagle and I’ll definitely be back! Food was great too. Give that Kelly a raise!!! More
Charles Saunders
05-04-2026
Amazing facility!
It's huge. Located in an old Federal building, the architecture is phenomenal. Inside, it has been reconfigured to create several different 'atmospheres'. Kind of hard to explain, but you can get comfortable in many different areas- the bar, long tables, round tables on the interior as well as tables with window seating. I also believe that there is an outdoor seating area on the second story. I believe that there is a pool table and some dart boards, also.
Many options of drinks available, I had the Ellicotville Blueberry Wheat draft, and Blueberry Cider, which both are delicious and I could drink a dozen of.
In fact, there are so many options that you will not be dissatisfied if you visit this establishment.
As for food, also so many options - too many to list so make sure you check out their menu online to see what they offer.
We ordered the Jumbo Pretzel which is served with a cream ale cheese sauce and Bavarian mustard. To be honest, it could easily be an appetizer for up to four people, if you are a light snacker.
Then, we ordered a half order of wings, and boneless wings.
The regular wings were absolutely delicious. Fried to a perfect crispness, coated perfectly with sauce. Not many places locally seem to be able to make wings correctly these days, but Ill Eagle nailed it! Boneless wings were ok, but not special.
The couple that we were with ordered a cheese steak sub, which came with actual sliced pieces of beef rather than steak ums, and a flatbread pizza that was a bit underwhelming, but was decent sized for one person.
Overall, will definitely return!!
Food: 5
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5
Brieanne Shaw
05-04-2026
Hosted a class reunion here recently. It was a great space for the event and the outdoor rooftop patio was a big hit with attendees. More
Taylor Gaetano
05-04-2026
Everything was amazing! My husband and I came for date night, and the food was outstanding! The bartender, Jemma, was so wonderful and made me the best espresso martini!!! We will be back 😊 … More
Samantha Ford
05-04-2026
This place is awesome! I highly suggest it. The food fantastic. Our server Kelly was friendly and knowledgeable about the building. The atmosphere was amazing. It at the old federal building and they did and excellent job of combining the old and new.
Holly Wilson
05-04-2026
You have to visit this place. Just the inside alone is worth it. There is tons of plenty of space to sit and enjoy the inside views. Food is fairly priced portions are generous! Must stop if you are passing through Elmira or want a historic feel while you eat!
Kristin Griffin
05-04-2026
Great for a quick lunch! Loved the variations of high tops, regular tables, even comfy chairs to sit in! Pizza was delicious too! More
JUNE GORDON
05-04-2026
Such a wonderful environment. For dinner, lunch or drinks, this is a nice establishment. Live groups play and sound is decent level except if you sit near them. But, that is self-explanatory. … More
Aubrey Wiles
05-04-2026
Such a cool atmosphere. Has a small menu but all the food is extremely tasty and fresh. The beer selection was extensive and staff allowed us to try beers before making decisions. As someone that loves sour beers I was excited to see that they had quite the collection. More
NYconcretejungle
05-04-2026
Attended a wedding here once. Very nice place just tried the food for the first time tonight. I had a steak quesadilla and it was amazing. I will be in this place alot more especially owning a business very close to them More
Charles Saunders
05-04-2026
Amazing facility!
It's huge. Located in an old Federal building, the architecture is phenomenal. … More
Ю
05-04-2026
The building is awesome. The food and drinks are good. The restrooms were probably not restrooms before because of the shiny and reflective marble floor... The people who worked there were very nice and professional. … More
Corey SMITH
05-04-2026
I truly enjoyed everything about this restaurant. The servers and bartenders are super friendly and knowledgeable about everything they have. I had the Smashburger, Italian Sausage bites, and Pork Bites. All of which were fantastic! They … More
Robert Gilchrist
05-04-2026
I fly to Elmira from NC almost weekly. The food is good, the drinks are good, and the service is great! Though I believe I’m the only southern (semi) regular, the staff and other regulars make me feel at home every visit. Love these guys! More
john iszard
05-04-2026
Amazing space with a restaurant, 2 bars, recreation space, roof deck, wine, beer full bar, what else can you ask for in warm inviting food and beverage one stop venue. More
George K
05-04-2026
We stayed 3 days in the the Corning/Elmira area and the "ill-Eagle Taphouse" was the best place to grab some food along with a solid selection of draft beers. We had the house salad with grilled chicken and the Mediterranean flat bread. … More
Slim Dog Studio
05-04-2026
Everything was great! Good food, decent prices, great atmosphere. Staff were kind and prompt. They could be dressed better - staff looking too casual for the feel of the place. Jogger shorts were not impressive but the person did the job perfectly. More
Lulu Lovetoeat
05-04-2026
Third time trying this place and it was no a third time is the charm experience. The first two times were good; however this time was fair. The staff was less than enthusiastic and most importantly you could not escape the smell of pot to … More
Shadra Bruce
05-04-2026
Really lovely pub with rooftop seating and delicious food at a decent price. The service was impeccable and the food was fresh and well made. Definitely a place we'll return to! More
Mark Edge
05-04-2026
3/22/25: Outstanding atmosphere and excellent service and food. This taphouse is located in one of the finest historic buildings in the Chemung County area. The owners have taken an empty building that has so much history and given the … More
Roy Shelley
05-04-2026
A little difficult to find, and space is multilevel and large. Seat yourself, order at the bar, and food is brought to the table. Grilled chicken club was delicious. Chips were surprisingly delicious. Wife enjoyed the grilled chicken salad. Wide selection of beers on tap. More
Reviews Ill Eagle Taphouse