Located at 905 Church Ave in the heart of Brooklyn, New York, Wheated has established itself as a distinctive destination for those who appreciate the intersection of traditional craftsmanship and local community spirit. The restaurant serves as a welcoming space where the focus remains steadfast on quality ingredients, thoughtful preparation, and an atmosphere that feels both refined and approachable. For residents of the neighborhood and visitors exploring the diverse culinary landscape of Brooklyn, Wheated offers an experience that prioritizes the integrity of its offerings above all else.
The philosophy behind the kitchen is rooted in a deep respect for the culinary arts. Rather than chasing fleeting trends, the establishment leans into time-honored techniques that highlight the natural flavors of high-quality produce and artisanal components. Every element of the menu is curated with intention, ensuring that each dish reflects a balance of texture, aroma, and taste. This commitment to excellence has made the venue a staple for those who seek a reliable, high-quality dining experience in a setting that celebrates the vibrant culture of the Church Avenue corridor.
Beyond the plate, the environment at Wheated is designed to foster connection. The interior reflects a thoughtful aesthetic that complements the culinary style, providing a comfortable backdrop for casual dinners, celebratory gatherings, or quiet evenings. By maintaining a consistent standard of service and a warm, inviting ambiance, the restaurant has successfully integrated itself into the fabric of the local community, serving as a gathering point that honors the history and the evolving character of Brooklyn.
Key Highlights of the Wheated Experience
Commitment to Quality Sourcing: The kitchen prioritizes the use of fresh, seasonal ingredients, working closely with suppliers to ensure that every component meets rigorous standards of quality and sustainability.
Artisanal Preparation Methods: By utilizing traditional techniques, the culinary team emphasizes the depth of flavor inherent in their ingredients, resulting in dishes that are both complex and satisfying.
Community-Centric Atmosphere: Situated in the heart of Brooklyn, the restaurant provides a welcoming space that reflects the neighborhood's unique energy, making it an ideal spot for both locals and visitors.
Thoughtful Culinary Curation: The menu is designed with a focus on balance and harmony, offering a selection that showcases a dedication to the craft of cooking without unnecessary complexity.
The dedication to the craft is evident in every aspect of the operation, from the initial selection of raw materials to the final presentation on the table. This meticulous approach ensures that guests are treated to a consistent and memorable experience, regardless of when they choose to visit. The team behind the restaurant understands that true hospitality is about more than just the food; it is about creating a space where people feel valued and where the quality of the meal is matched by the quality of the environment.
As the culinary scene in Brooklyn continues to evolve, Wheated remains a steadfast presence, grounded in its original mission to provide honest, well-prepared food. The restaurant invites guests to slow down and appreciate the nuances of a well-executed meal, encouraging a dining culture that values patience and appreciation for the process. Whether you are a long-time resident of the area or someone passing through the vibrant streets of Brooklyn, a visit to this Church Avenue establishment offers a glimpse into a philosophy that places the guest and the ingredient at the center of the experience.
In an era where dining options are vast and varied, finding a place that maintains such a clear and focused identity is a rare pleasure. The team at Wheated continues to refine their approach, always looking for ways to enhance the guest experience while staying true to the principles that have defined them from the beginning. It is this blend of consistency, passion, and community engagement that ensures the restaurant remains a meaningful part of the local dining landscape for years to come.
For those interested in experiencing a meal that honors the traditions of quality cooking in a modern, comfortable setting, Wheated stands as a testament to what can be achieved when passion meets purpose. The doors are open to those who appreciate the finer details of a well-prepared dish and the warmth of a space designed for genuine human connection. We invite you to visit 905 Church Ave and discover the unique character that defines this Brooklyn landmark.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Service options
Outdoor seating
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery
Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great wine list
Popular for
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Hard liquor
Late-night food
Vegan options
Vegetarian options
Wine
Dining options
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Bar onsite
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Free Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy
Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Parking
Free street parking
Paid street parking
Menus
Pizza Menu
Mixed Greens$9.00
Caesar Salad**$9.00
Summer Salad$8.00
Ditmas Park$10.00
Park Slope$13.00
Kensington*$13.00
Brooklyn Heights*
Gravesend*$13.00
Bensonhurst$13.00
Caton Park*$14.00
Borough Park*$14.00
Vinegar Hill*$14.00
Red Hook*$15.00
Brighton Beach*$15.00
Coney Island 2.0$15.00
Sunset Park$15.00
East Williamsburg*$15.00
Clinton Hill$15.00
Fort Greene*$14.00
Bay Ridge$13.00
Manhattan Beach*$13.00
Windsor Terrace*$16.00
Tomato Sauce$1.00
Roasted Onions$1.00
Fresh Spicy Jalapenos$1.00
Drink Menu
Seelbach$10.00
Bourbon Manhattan$9.00
Horses Neck$9.00
Bourbon Smash$9.00
New York Sour$9.00
Mint Julep$9.00
Blood and Sand$10.00
Penicillin$10.00
French 75$10.00
Negroni$10.00
Gin & Tonic$9.00
Pimm's Cup$10.00
Moscow Mule$9.00
Cuba Libre$9.00
Bitter Mai Tai$10.00
Capirinha$8.00
Paloma$9.00
Margarita$9.00
Mezcal Cup$10.00
Blanco Old Fashioned$10.00
Bordeaux, La Fleur Du Roi
Vitiano Umbria, Falesco
Chianti Cetamura, Badia A Coltobuono
Primo Nero, Li Veli
Valpolicella DOC, Zenato
Albarino, Condes de Albarei
Chenin Blanc + Viognier, Pine Ridge
Viognier, Yalumba Y Serie
Reisling, Clean Slate
inot Grigio, St. Michael Eppan
Le Rosé di Regaleali Sicilia, Tasca D'Alerita
Le Petit Gueissard, Les Vignobles Guiessard
Cuvee Brut Vino, Zardetto Private
House Ginger and Lime$3.00
House White Cola$3.00
Sprecher Root Beer$4.00
Sprecher Cream Soda$4.00
Sprecher Orange Cream Soda$4.00
Mexican Coke$3.00
Diet Coke$1.50
Photos
Reviews Wheated
Alyssa D.
30-05-2026
Came for dinner with friends. There was a slight wait but totally okay. The pizzas were delicious with very fresh ingredients. Cocktails were also very nice. The staff were attentive and sweet. Would definitely come back! More
Stephanie Mardell
30-05-2026
We have been going to Wheated almost for 3 years and it never disappoints. It’s one of those places where they truly care about their customers. Craig, one of the servers is so warm and welcoming - even when it gets super busy he somehow … More
Katy Li
30-05-2026
Amazing neighborhood pizza and bar. Their pizza combinations are a must try and they have great cocktails to go with it. Must try to dip the crust in their homemade chili oil. Fire 🔥! … More
Matteo Ruggiu
30-05-2026
The setup at Wheated is the classic neighborhood spot—bar up front, tables in back, open kitchen so you can watch your pizza go into the oven. It's cozy without trying too hard, and the vibe is welcoming whether you're here for a quick … More
Jamie Jenkins
30-05-2026
Amazing pizza, delicious cocktails, and the kindest, most generous staff you could hope for. Everything tasted incredible and the service made the whole experience feel extra special. Can’t wait to go back! More
Andrew Richter
30-05-2026
I'd like to open with an apology to the host on 11/15 for my rudeness. I walked out in frustration because this is the third or fourth time I've planned my entire day around showing up the minute they open, weekend or weekday, and was … More
Nikita Stepanov
30-05-2026
Fantastic pizza, great bar. Exceptional service. Expect a long wait if you don't show up at 5pm as it opens. I been here a couple times but allways showing up at 5 so we managed to get a table. More
Jeff T
30-05-2026
I’ve been coming here for 10+ years and it never disappoints! Great food, phenomenal staff! All I can say is well worth the trip !!! More
Kenneth Munz
30-05-2026
What happened????? I keep trying to come back post covid and find myself disappointed every time. Pizza tonight was hard, very chewy, like a flatbread. Guessing the dough was overproofed, but this seems to be the norm now. We switched … More
Ben Kilburn
30-05-2026
Gem of a restaurant! Truly some of my favorite pizza in NYC after 10 years of living here. I've been a few times now and they always live up to my hopes. Excellent pizza in a few different styles with great topping options, and very … More
Safi Bi
30-05-2026
Pizza and cocktails were both delicious. Staff was really friendly but it was a little disappointing that no mention of the hot oil or honey were made. The place also gets super busy. Would love a beef option. All of their meat option is … More
William Chu
30-05-2026
If you want good pizza, this is good pizza. We had the sunset park pie, the New Haven and the bay ridge. Amazing, just amazing. The drinks were pretty good as well. The bathroom is very clean too. Always impressed with clean bathrooms ! More
Cynthia Chaldekas
30-05-2026
I ordered 2 pies to go: New Haven white onion and potato and the Coney Island. The New Haven is a new pizza on their menu and it’s a good one. Subtle in flavor but oh so good, the potatoes are sliced super thin, barely noticeable really and … More
Charles Diamond
30-05-2026
One of the best pizzas I've ever had, certainly the best pizza in the neighborhood. Their selection of specialty pies is interesting, but the underlying elements, the sauce, the dough, the cheese, the toppings, they're all top notch. The bar is terrific, they make amazing cocktails, great beer selection, and the staff are delightful. More
chris caracciolo
30-05-2026
Busy neighborhood spot. The service is great . The host is warm, pleasant, and very accommodating . The service was also on point . Ordered a Manhattan. It definitely was nothing short of spot on and a perfect start to the meal. … More
Maggie Milke
30-05-2026
Great drinks fantabulous service and such good pizza. Arugula salad was unbelievably delicious. Its defo poppin but worth the wait. Ask server for theyre homeade pizza sesame topping More
Andrew Dabydeen
30-05-2026
Wheated probably takes the crown for some of the best specialty pizzas in Brooklyn. We absolutely loved our dinner here. The space has a fast, lively energy that makes it feel like you’re in on a neighborhood favorite, and the food completely lives up to the buzz.
One of the coolest touches is that every pizza is named after a Brooklyn neighborhood, which makes the menu fun to explore. I ordered the Flatbush and it honestly surprised me in the best way. I had never tried eggplant on pizza before, but it worked incredibly well. It added a rich, savory depth without feeling heavy, and the crust had that perfect balance of chewy and crisp.
The cocktails were also a pleasant surprise. It’s not always expected at a pizza spot, but they were thoughtfully made and paired perfectly with the meal.
Everything about Wheated just clicked, from the energy of the room to the quality of the food. This is the kind of place you leave already planning what you’ll order next time. I cannot wait to come back. 🍕🔥
Order type
Dine in
Price per person
$30–40
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Group size
2 people
Wait time
No wait
Recommendation for vegetarians
Highly recommend
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free street parking, Paid street parking
Roberto A
30-05-2026
I have no idea what people find special about their pizza. We had the Sunset Park pie and a Red Hook pizza and they were absolutely average in taste and had a terrible texture more like a shoe sole. They were very overcooked and dry. Weird. Will give them a second chance if n a few month. Let’s see. More
Zachary Perlstein
30-05-2026
Ordered the bay ridge pie to go and after the first bite I was in heaven. An amazing, tasty and crispy slice. The only negatives was the price and that I should’ve ordered 2 pies because me and my friend devoured the whole pie in seconds. More
John Santaferraro
30-05-2026
WOW, WOW, WOW! I know that Michelin has their three stars, well I give Wheated my three wows for the triple wow experience I had there last night. Every person serving us was exceedingly talented at what they did and extremely personal in … More
Brendan Egan
30-05-2026
Not sure how I haven’t rated sooner, we absolutely love this place. The pizza is always incredible, the meatballs are definitely a sleeper hit on the apps. But last night we were there and the Bay Ridge (a vodka pie) was just out of this … More
Scott Miranda
30-05-2026
My son is GF so he ate before I did here. Came just after 5 so the dining area was packed!
But... they allowed me, my son, and my daughter to enjoy dinner at the bar. You guys were awesome and entertaining while my kids poked at the salad and stole the cherry from my Manhattan lol.
Arugula salad was nice and the Pizza, even better! Added onion and mushrooms to the Bay Ridge that I ordered and tried with the spicy crunch added.
Gave great recommendations and we're really attentive. Thank you for this great meal!
I'll be back when I can!
Price per person
$50–60
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Kraig DeMatteis
30-05-2026
Picked-up dinner but I want to come back to eat-in. Their bar counter overlooks their wide selection of bourbons and whiskeys in a cozy wood-covered interior. I did not order dinner myself but apparently you need to reserve spots for … More
Areum Kim
30-05-2026
The hot sopressata pie was good but it was really the vodka pie that blew me away. Their crust is definitely something special. Caesar salad was also a standout of the meal. Wonderful service. Came with friends on a Friday evening and it … More
Scott Miranda
30-05-2026
My son is GF so he ate before I did here. Came just after 5 so the dining area was packed! … More
Brooklyn PC
30-05-2026
From the moment we walked in, we knew this would be something special. The pizzas were absolutely phenomenal. The arugula pie was fresh and perfectly balanced, the classic Margherita was full of bold flavor, and the meatballs? Out of this … More
Andrea Posada Colavizza
30-05-2026
Amazing pizza! Despite we had to wait over 1 hour, the service was good and the pizza was so delicious, that i would definitely come back!!!
Price per person
$40–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Reservation
Reservations recommended
Group size
3-4 people
Recommendation for vegetarians
Highly recommend
Vegetarian offerings
Vegetarian menu or section
Parking space
Not sure
Lourdes Echagarruga
30-05-2026
We popped in and it was busy. Luckily they had 3 seats at the bar. 10/10 would recommend. We got 2 12" pizzas and it was perfect for 3 people. We took home a few slices. Both pizzas were delicious.
The ceasar salad was also outstanding
Order type
Dine in
Price per person
$40–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Group size
2 people
Wait time
No wait
Josh Spare
30-05-2026
I just moved over to the Flatbush area from the city and I was looking for a solid local pizza spot you can dine it at. This is the one! Been twice and both times the pizza was phenomenal (top 10 in all of NYC good). The atmosphere and ambiance is great and it is good for families or just a date night. I highly recommend this spot and I will become a regular soon!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Dwight Kenneth
30-05-2026
First Impressions & Vibe:
We popped in on a Saturday with no reservation and were seated within 10 minutes. The place was busy, or “bumping,” as you said. The atmosphere is cool, casual, lively, neighborhood pizza spot energy.
⸻
🥗 Salad + Starters
We tried the Tuscan Kale salad. The cheese was nice and nutty, and the walnuts added a good texture. But the dressing was too acidic — the moment you bite in, the tang hits first and lingers. It overpowered the greens instead of complementing them.
⸻
🍕 Pizza & Side
We went with a classic New York style pie, 12-inch split between two people. Served correctly, satisfying size — we didn’t leave hungry. It’s the kind of pizza you expect from a pizza place: decent cheese, but teg crust was BURNT , but overall “good.”
But I have to call out a few details:
1. The bacon side was disappointing. It tasted more like honey ham than bacon. It lacked the fattiness, crispiness, texture contrast you want from bacon.
2. They even served it with a side of ketchup, which felt odd
3. The execution of the pizza was fine, but nothing popped. The food didn’t “wow” me.
I will say that their menu offers a wide range of “sourdough pizzas” and “special pizzas” in different styles which I found interesting!
🍹 Drinks & Service
We didn’t try any cocktails this time, so can’t speak much on that front. The service was average — nothing bad, nothing that stood out. Exactly what you’d expect: professional, steady, no major slip-ups.
⸻
🔍 Final Thoughts
Wheated is a solid neighborhood pizza spot. It has thoughtful craft behind its dough and menu concepts. Its strengths lie in variety, ambition, and decent pricing. But on this visit, the food didn’t fully deliver — the salad was overpowered, the bacon was off, and the pizza was good but not memorable.
Would I go back? Yes — probably more for drinks next time, and maybe experimenting with other pizzas, or to see if another visit hits harder.
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 3
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 4
Reservation
Reservations recommended
Group size
2 people
lee Vogel
30-05-2026
Definitely one of the TOP Pie spots in Brooklyn!
Love the aesthetics! The bathroom door blending into the wall is cool! I don’t remember that last time I was here to dine-in but that was a while ago. I’ve done both take-out & dine-in here.
There were a couple tables available but they do fill up fast! I found a seat by the bar right away!
I ordered a drink while I waited I don’t remember the name but it was good.
The Pizza came after like 15min or so it wasn’t a long wait. I was really happy with its presentation, flavor & texture etc…
The cheese was perfectly melted, the crust was crispy & sauce was great! They definitely didn’t disappoint & piled high the toppings for the supreme part of the pie. I would definitely get the supreme again though next time I wanna try a white pie maybe the New Haven rosemary potato pie sounds good as a next try. I would also highly recommend the Flatbush for all the Eggplant lovers out there!
The service was good, the staff was attentive to my needs & were friendly.
Order type
Dine in
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 4
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 4
Group size
2 people
Wait time
No wait
Recommendation for vegetarians
Not sure
Vegetarian offerings
Not sure
Parking space
Somewhat difficult to find parking
Parking options
Free street parking, Paid street parking
Parking
If you come after 7pm you can park by the meters free. If you come before the restaurant opens like between 1-3pm you have a higher chance of finding free street parking & during the meantime while you wait for the restaurant to open you can check out prospect park & there are some other things nearby as well
Reviews Wheated